Elijah Moore or Random 23 1st

[lt1hawk337]

I am a huge Elijah Moore fan, but I am convinced they are going to draft someone bigger, with better draft capital this year.

Which would you rather have and why? Moore or a random 23 1st? I'd like to cash in on the hype since I picked him up at the 2.04 last year, but don't want to just give him away.

[Gator Sens]

If the pick has a realistic shot at being early to mid, the value is on the pick side based on the value and hype of the class. If likely late, hold.

[SoftwoodGrampian]

Wash

[StripesOfKC]

Post the team and format of the team whose pick it is

I can go either way

Leaning slightly to Moore because I think the Jets offense improves enough but a real shitty team would change my mind

[FantasyFreak]

Drake London would be perfect for Moore. A guy that's a totally different skill set. G Wilson would be more problematic.

[MacDaddy123]

I would gamble on the pick here. 2023 class should be very good.
Elijah Moore MAY be better than pick 1.11 or 1.12, but I would want a top 10 pick in 2023 over Moore.

I mean even a chance to land Bijan Robinson, Zach Evans, Jahmyr Gibbs, Jaxon Smith-Njiba, Kayshon Boutte, Tank Bigbsy, etc., would be well worth the gamble of trading away Elijah Moore.

[MacDaddy123]

Drake London would be perfect for Moore. A guy that's a totally different skill set. G Wilson would be more problematic.

Those are 2022 WR's. The OP is asking about trading Elijah Moore for a random 2023 1st round pick.
That is an easy yes for me, as the 2023 class is loaded.

[murphysxm]

I lean the pick side as well

[meineymoe]

If this is for the team in your sig, you are a ways from contending, and I don't see Moore as a building block. I'd rather add another 1st rd pick while you can still get one for him.

Good luck!
-oo-

[YouMightDieTryin]

Drake London would be perfect for Moore. A guy that's a totally different skill set. G Wilson would be more problematic.

Those are 2022 WR's. The OP is asking about trading Elijah Moore for a random 2023 1st round pick.
That is an easy yes for me, as the 2023 class is loaded.

He's saying that if the Jets drafted London it would compliment Moore well, but if they draft Wilson then it's going to eat into what Moore can do production wise.

It's a real dilemma, but I think you favor the random '23 tbh.

[lt1hawk337]

I put out some offers for random 23 1sts prior to the draft and didn't get any takers. Ironically, I was able to move Toney and the 2.02 this year for a 23 1st....which was kind of a head scratcher for me.

I am good with holding Moore for now, but I was hoping to get some potential points off my team to lock up the 1.01, while also earning another 23rd 1st for Moore. I fear I am at the point where I am not good enough to compete, but too good to earn the 1.01 next year.

[Anteaters]

I put out some offers for random 23 1sts prior to the draft and didn't get any takers.

Not surprising. Moore's value took a big hit after NY drafted GWilson.

I am good with holding Moore for now, but I was hoping to get some potential points off my team to lock up the 1.01, while also earning another 23rd 1st for Moore. I fear I am at the point where I am not good enough to compete, but too good to earn the 1.01 next year.

If you're all in on a full rebuild that has you in contention for a T3 draft pick, I would start asking for '24 1sts. Unless GWilson is a bust, Moore's ceiling is going to be a WR3. If that's Moore's future, you're better off resetting and hoping the new pick hits the lottery for you. If no one wanted to give a '24 1st for him (which I understand because I would not either) then I'd accept a '23 2nd.

If you can't trade him for a projected high 2nd, then I'd hold him. But I'd hold with the expectation that I'm holding a roster clogger and/or three times a year bye-week or injury fill-in. I'd also use him as a sweetener to facilitate other trades.

I simply don't see any realistic outcome that has EMoore as a T20 fantasy WR in NY.

[yinzername]

^ even with Wislon getting drafted, this is by far the lowest take on EMoore I've seen. WR1 ceiling is easily still on the table. GW has never played a pro snap, and Moore already put together a solid sampling of week in and week out WR1 play

I agree that he's an early 2nd value/hold, but I would absolutely try for a late 1st in any Moore trade negotiation were i to try and move him. It is not unreasonable to think that someone would make that slight overpay from about 2.2 to 1.11ish

And that floor is straight ridiculous. Even if GW balls out, a 3-spot starts per season expectation for E Moore is laughable. You should glance at current NFL trends for 3WR sets and team WR2 numbers. I'm curious where you rank E Moore against guys like Mike Williams, Gabe Davis, Renfrew, Lockett, etc...Lastly, considering NYJ's glowing analyses around recent drafts and improved skill position play, there is a lot of possible upside out there to bolster all Jets player values and prospects at the moment

[Anteaters]

I'm curious where you rank E Moore against guys like Mike Williams, Gabe Davis, Renfrew, Lockett, etc...Lastly, considering NYJ's glowing analyses around recent drafts and improved skill position play, there is a lot of possible upside out there to bolster all Jets player values and prospects at the moment

Heading into the 2022 season...
MWilliams = Renfrow > Lockett = Gabe > EMoore
I have a gap after Renfrow. The gap between Gabe and EMoore is microscopic, but I put Gabe ahead because Josh>>>Zach and the BUF offense is a proven commodity >> NYJ Offense.

I'm well aware of NFL WR sets. I think EMoore will be a very good real world player for NYJ, but he'll be JAG as a fantasy WR. EMoore was ~WR30 in ppg in 2021, with solid but unspectacular competition for receptions. but it was an offense that spread the ball around. With Garrett added to EMoore and CDavis, I don't see any of them placing better than WR24 on the season. If Davis plays all season he'll siphon targets from Moore. If Garrett proves competent, he'll siphon targets from Moore.

With a better QB and a better offense, MWilliams was a low-end WR2 last season. I have a hard time predicting EMoore to outdo that in his current situation.