Blockbuster trade offered to me

[the_lung]

I used the DLF Trade Analyzer and there is a calculated difference of 247.5 (14.9%) loss in this proposed trade to me. However, I am still considering it. Your thoughts?

12 team, 1 QB league with 1.0 PPR.

Team B offers:
Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB
Cook, Dalvin MIN RB
Harry, N'Keal NEP WR
Hurst, Hayden ATL TE
Year 2020 Draft Pick 1.09

I give up: (Team A)
Rivers, Philip IND QB
Chubb, Nick CLE RB
Brown, A.J. TEN WR
Higbee, Tyler LAR TE
Year 2020 Draft Pick 1.07

My roster (Team A)

Garoppolo, Jimmy SFO QB
Rivers, Philip IND QB

Chubb, Nick CLE RB
Drake, Kenyan ARI RB
Lindsay, Phillip DEN RB
Johnson, Kerryon DET RB
Cohen, Tarik CHI RB
Williams, Jamaal GBP RB
Burkhead, Rex NEP RB

Jones, Julio ATL WR
Godwin, Chris TBB WR
Allen, Keenan LAC WR
Brown, A.J. TEN WR
Jones, Marvin DET WR
Brown, John BUF WR
Jeffery, Alshon PHI WR
Dorsett, Phillip SEA WR
Davis, Corey TEN WR

Higbee, Tyler LAR TE
Eifert, Tyler JAC TE

Prater, Matt DET PK
Saints, New Orleans NOS Def

Would you accept the trade?

[FantasyFoosball]

No.

[J. Edgar]

Keep your side easily.

[Ruggenater]

Agreed, keep your side.

[MyTeam]

I view it as:

Rodgers>=Rivers - With the Love pick there is really no security for Rodgers after this year.
Cook>=Chubb - I am not super high on either of these RBs due to Cook injury prone and Chubbs second half of the year didn't look too good.
Harry<<AJ Brown
Hurst=Higbee
1.09<1.07

Keep your side. I wouldn't take it because the step down from AJ Brown to Harry is huge and you lose a couple spots on the picks for not really much added.

[abloom]

Pass. I think the offer is close but definitely want your side more

[Dusticlez1]

Eww no, basically paying up for the Arod upgrade to Rivers. Look elsewhere

[the_lung]

Thanks for the immediate feedback, guys. Y'all rule!

[Gator Sens]

Definitely hold here.

[24FlavorsofFun]

Why would you even consider it? I'm genuinely curious.

Team B offers:
Rodgers, Aaron GBP QB > Rivers, Philip IND QB
Cook, Dalvin MIN RB =< Chubb, Nick CLE RB
Harry, N'Keal NEP WR <<< Brown, A.J. TEN WR
Hurst, Hayden ATL TE < Higbee, Tyler LAR TE
Year 2020 Draft Pick 1.09 < Year 2020 Draft Pick 1.07

Every single piece of that deal is a loss from you aside form Rodgers. And after the draft his situation is all kinds of murky.

[Space Cowboy]

I view it as:

Rodgers>=Rivers - With the Love pick there is really no security for Rodgers after this year.
Cook>=Chubb - I am not super high on either of these RBs due to Cook injury prone and Chubbs second half of the year didn't look too good.
Harry<<AJ Brown
Hurst=Higbee
1.09<1.07

Keep your side. I wouldn't take it because the step down from AJ Brown to Harry is huge and you lose a couple spots on the picks for not really much added.

Higbee is way more talented but too many TEs on LAR. Anyway TEs or not you're giving too much.

[Needalife]

I’d take the deal if you could remove AJB and Harry. Otherwise no deal.

[NFL123]

Definitely stay where you are. Aside from the other downgrades, there is a drop in talent from 1.07 to 1.09. Understand you wanting to upgrade from Rivers, but look elsewhere.

[jjleurquin]

If you've got some interest in the deal, he definitely has to give up more.

[mmass]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! it's a trap