Mixon/HunterHenry or Woods/Ertz/1st

[Martpe]

In a 0.5 PPR, 1 QB (starting 2 RB, 3WR, 2 flex), which side will you pick for a mid-range team?
Note: owner of the 1st is currently 6-1 and will almost certainly end season in top4

[Gator Sens]

Mixon and Henry for a middle team. Go young.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Late 1st >= Henry
Ertz + Woods > Mixon

[SHIZZLE]

mixon hype has ended and the results are in......hes not good, he's on a bad offense, but so was AP on the vikings yet he was still productive. hunter is good, but rivers is gone soon. I would easily take Ertz, woods and a 1st. that 1st will get you a RB that's better than mixon. Ertz is a buy low right now coming off a few down weeks.

this whole late 1st >= Henry thing has no context, its a quick reply, but is very vague.

[Slackalacker]

I don’t think there’s any way you get an rb close to Mixon with a late 1st but I still believe in him. I want the Mixon side but it’s close

[Straycatz2]

Curious, do people think Mixon is bad or the cincy offense is just historically aweful and don't know how to use Mixon? Chris thompson, 3rd down back, whose hurt, missed games, and on a terrible team as well has more points.

It seems like talented RB can still find ways to be fantasy relevant. For example DJ has always been decent and close to top 12 RB even when cardinals was hot garbage (maybe worst oline) and got the #1 overall pick. Barkley is amazing no matter how bad giants are.