Traded proposal?

[Dwstull81]

Another owner wants Rodgers. Reasonable, not enough, or bad proposal by me to him?

Aaron Rodgers

For
Jameis Winston, Brandin Cooks, and 1.11

[ManhattanProject]

What is the scoring? Is this superflex or 2 qb? Unless this league somehow skews HEAVILY towards qb I think you're asking too much.

[Chandler Bing]

Very bad proposal. Cooks is worth more than Rodgers alone unless that is super flex or 2qb

[Benny5]

Another owner wants Rodgers. Reasonable, not enough, or bad proposal by me to him?

Aaron Rodgers

For
Jameis Winston, Brandin Cooks, and 1.11

1 qb league or superflex?
That's not enough in a 1qb league.
Also, why are you coming up with the proposal if he came to you for one of the elite QBs??? That's a sure fire way to either go too low or give them ideas as to what they can get away with. I'd flat say, I love the guy and it'd take a lot for me to part with him, what are you looking to give me?

I gave up a ton to get Rodgers. I wouldn't even consider Winston Cooks and the 1.11 ... more like the 1.1 and some futures plus another elite position. If it's 1qb league they better come with way more than what I just outlined as well... In superflex you could get by with Mahomes and Winston... 1qb no way am I giving up Rodgers for a boom or bust receiver, a boom or bust qb, and a 1.11 which likely won't be an elite guy.

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

Need lineup information and league size. Those affect the value of top QBs a ton.

[Dwstull81]

1 qb league. Didn't actually offer it. Was thinking of proposals and what's fair. From responses, seems like that's a bad offer. Finding it kind of hard to figure Rodgers value, especially in 1 QB league.

[joeday]

1 qb league. Didn't actually offer it. Was thinking of proposals and what's fair. From responses, seems like that's a bad offer. Finding it kind of hard to figure Rodgers value, especially in 1 QB league.

Take out the 1.11 and try it.

[Bisquiteen Trisket]

Another owner wants Rodgers. Reasonable, not enough, or bad proposal by me to him?

Aaron Rodgers

For
Jameis Winston, Brandin Cooks, and 1.11

1 qb league or superflex?
That's not enough in a 1qb league.
Also, why are you coming up with the proposal if he came to you for one of the elite QBs??? That's a sure fire way to either go too low or give them ideas as to what they can get away with. I'd flat say, I love the guy and it'd take a lot for me to part with him, what are you looking to give me?

I gave up a ton to get Rodgers. I wouldn't even consider Winston Cooks and the 1.11 ... more like the 1.1 and some futures plus another elite position. If it's 1qb league they better come with way more than what I just outlined as well... In superflex you could get by with Mahomes and Winston... 1qb no way am I giving up Rodgers for a boom or bust receiver, a boom or bust qb, and a 1.11 which likely won't be an elite guy.

So much of this confuses me. You paid more than Winston, Cooks and 1.11 to get Rodgers in a 1QB league? You think Rodgers is worth 1.1, an elite asset and future picks in a 1QB league??? You also stated that QBs are more valuable in a 1QB league?

No offense but I disagree with everything you stated. Can you please explain your logic?

[BradysBunch]

In any format, I think that is an overpay for Rodgers. If you can get it, great. I personally have offered the 1.8 and Winston for Rodgers...I won't go higher.

[RB6]

You're asking way too much. I'd try Winston and the 1.11. Or Cooks straight up.

[knotts4372]

Another owner wants Rodgers. Reasonable, not enough, or bad proposal by me to him?

Aaron Rodgers

For
Jameis Winston, Brandin Cooks, and 1.11

1 qb league or superflex?
That's not enough in a 1qb league.
Also, why are you coming up with the proposal if he came to you for one of the elite QBs??? That's a sure fire way to either go too low or give them ideas as to what they can get away with. I'd flat say, I love the guy and it'd take a lot for me to part with him, what are you looking to give me?

I gave up a ton to get Rodgers. I wouldn't even consider Winston Cooks and the 1.11 ... more like the 1.1 and some futures plus another elite position. If it's 1qb league they better come with way more than what I just outlined as well... In superflex you could get by with Mahomes and Winston... 1qb no way am I giving up Rodgers for a boom or bust receiver, a boom or bust qb, and a 1.11 which likely won't be an elite guy.

lmfao if you paid a ton for rodgers or any qb in a 1qb league thats on you but stop giving advice on here if you think hes worth that much in 1qb cause that isnt helping newbies. you should prob be the one asking for advice so you stop making horrible trades

[FantasyFreak]

Another owner wants Rodgers. Reasonable, not enough, or bad proposal by me to him?

Aaron Rodgers

For
Jameis Winston, Brandin Cooks, and 1.11

1 qb league or superflex?
That's not enough in a 1qb league.
Also, why are you coming up with the proposal if he came to you for one of the elite QBs??? That's a sure fire way to either go too low or give them ideas as to what they can get away with. I'd flat say, I love the guy and it'd take a lot for me to part with him, what are you looking to give me?

I gave up a ton to get Rodgers. I wouldn't even consider Winston Cooks and the 1.11 ... more like the 1.1 and some futures plus another elite position. If it's 1qb league they better come with way more than what I just outlined as well... In superflex you could get by with Mahomes and Winston... 1qb no way am I giving up Rodgers for a boom or bust receiver, a boom or bust qb, and a 1.11 which likely won't be an elite guy.

I don't know what to say other than this is way off. 1 QB league devalues the position. If you proposed what is in bold you would end up in the "For Fun: Worst Trade Offers" thread. That is, let's say highly inaccurate to think Rodgers is worth that in a 1 QB league.

[colonnaj94]

In a 1 QB league, give me Cooks straight up over Rodgers.

[Benny5]

Another owner wants Rodgers. Reasonable, not enough, or bad proposal by me to him?

Aaron Rodgers

For
Jameis Winston, Brandin Cooks, and 1.11

1 qb league or superflex?
That's not enough in a 1qb league.
Also, why are you coming up with the proposal if he came to you for one of the elite QBs??? That's a sure fire way to either go too low or give them ideas as to what they can get away with. I'd flat say, I love the guy and it'd take a lot for me to part with him, what are you looking to give me?

I gave up a ton to get Rodgers. I wouldn't even consider Winston Cooks and the 1.11 ... more like the 1.1 and some futures plus another elite position. If it's 1qb league they better come with way more than what I just outlined as well... In superflex you could get by with Mahomes and Winston... 1qb no way am I giving up Rodgers for a boom or bust receiver, a boom or bust qb, and a 1.11 which likely won't be an elite guy.

So much of this confuses me. You paid more than Winston, Cooks and 1.11 to get Rodgers in a 1QB league? You think Rodgers is worth 1.1, an elite asset and future picks in a 1QB league??? You also stated that QBs are more valuable in a 1QB league?

No offense but I disagree with everything you stated. Can you please explain your logic?

I was away for a while and I see my post has lead to confusion... for a 1qb league I don't value Winston much at all. Cooks the same. And a 1.11 is a lotto ticket... if it's only a 10 team league sure any QB will do. If it's a 14 team league I'm not giving up Rodgers.

For my own trade, it's a dual QB super flex, and I'm a packers fan and the other owner loved Rodgers as well so of course I overpaid.

[Benny5]

Another owner wants Rodgers. Reasonable, not enough, or bad proposal by me to him?

Aaron Rodgers

For
Jameis Winston, Brandin Cooks, and 1.11

1 qb league or superflex?
That's not enough in a 1qb league.
Also, why are you coming up with the proposal if he came to you for one of the elite QBs??? That's a sure fire way to either go too low or give them ideas as to what they can get away with. I'd flat say, I love the guy and it'd take a lot for me to part with him, what are you looking to give me?

I gave up a ton to get Rodgers. I wouldn't even consider Winston Cooks and the 1.11 ... more like the 1.1 and some futures plus another elite position. If it's 1qb league they better come with way more than what I just outlined as well... In superflex you could get by with Mahomes and Winston... 1qb no way am I giving up Rodgers for a boom or bust receiver, a boom or bust qb, and a 1.11 which likely won't be an elite guy.

lmfao if you paid a ton for rodgers or any qb in a 1qb league thats on you but stop giving advice on here if you think hes worth that much in 1qb cause that isnt helping newbies. you should prob be the one asking for advice so you stop making horrible trades

My league is 2qb superflex. I should've clarified. And yes, 1qb leagues QBs way less valuable but to me Winston won't be that good, and now with this media circus that has happened since this post... appears I was also correct to not want Wilson over Rodgers. My teams are in my sig if you were wanting to laugh enough... you'd see I can definitely handle trades and build rosters but that's on you.