Zay Jones Debate Plus

[esloan35]

Traded Zay for 3.2 and got some grief. 26th player in this draft over a guy with bad handles seems good to me. Then I was told Marvin Jones is worth 4.4 and Jeremy Hill is worth at least as much. Frustrated owner I guess. Am I missing something?

[Bay City Original]

I probably wouldn't have let Zay go so soon... and if I did, I'd want a mid-2nd.

[esloan35]

Fair enough, but whoever pays a mid 2nd for a Bills WR who was ranked 95th last year is reaching imo. I would rather reach with the 3rd in this draft. I would of gladly sent him to you for 2.5.

[jp4703]

WRs aren’t like Rbs where you get instant results. You have to give WRs 2-3 years to show their potential. Zay jones is in a situation where he’s going to continue to get playing time. You shouldn’t give up a player in a situation like that to go draft another player hoping he gets put into a similar situation.

It’s way to soon to give up on him. I actually think he’s going to be a solid wr.

[Bot101]

I would have held Zay. Everyone is quick to forget that he had a nice breakout game mid season vs the Jets and it would have been even better had he not been tackled in a dirty way which caused a pretty significant injury. He also played with a torn labrum the entire season. His father even said Zay had a hard time holding a cup of water he was in so much pain. He also had the highest percentage of uncatchable passes thrown his way.

[DynastyDeepDive]

I would have held Zay to. 3rd round picks are crap shoots.

[philsrule06]

Dumb trade. This is the same type of trade that ends up haunting a dynasty owner. How many people gave up on a player like Nelson Agholor? He was probably traded for a low pick or even released in many leagues. Need a little patience. Much rather hold a young player a little too long and having him not pan out over trading him for junk & watching him flourish a year or two later.

[esloan35]

Good points... will hold the trigger a bit longer next time. Thanks for the feedback.

[McCloskey22]

Biased Zay owner - but I would have kept him. He had a rough 1st season, but that offense with Tyrod was a mess. Hopefully they get a young QB who opens the playbook up a little. Zay has a long ways to go but I still believe in him. I don't think it is wise, in dynasty, to ditch every player who dissapoints in their rookie season

[RB6]

Agree with others, should've held over a 3rd. I'd need a mid 2nd.

[Goddard]

Traded Zay for 3.2 and got some grief. 26th player in this draft over a guy with bad handles seems good to me. Then I was told Marvin Jones is worth 4.4 and Jeremy Hill is worth at least as much. Frustrated owner I guess. Am I missing something?

That's funny

[esloan35]

Traded Zay for 3.2 and got some grief. 26th player in this draft over a guy with bad handles seems good to me. Then I was told Marvin Jones is worth 4.4 and Jeremy Hill is worth at least as much. Frustrated owner I guess. Am I missing something?

That's funny

Sounds like by the board I sold short on Zay, but the Hill/Marvin Jones miffs me.

[Goddard]

Traded Zay for 3.2 and got some grief. 26th player in this draft over a guy with bad handles seems good to me. Then I was told Marvin Jones is worth 4.4 and Jeremy Hill is worth at least as much. Frustrated owner I guess. Am I missing something?

That's funny

Sounds like by the board I sold short on Zay, but the Hill/Marvin Jones miffs me.

I probably would have taken the 3.02 as well. I don't think Zay will ever really be much of a fantasy producer.

[esloan35]

Its probably my league mates commenting. LOL

[diamonddave]

zay's as much as a crapshoot as an early 3rd. six in one hand, half dozen in another. i say it's not a bad trade at all.