Rookie Rankings

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

Top 15ish rookies for me (off the top of my head - primarily play PPR):
*** Tier 1 ***
Fournette
Hunt
Cook
*** Tier 2 *** (more like 1.5 - much closer to tier 1 than tier 3)
Davis
CMC
Mixon
*** Tier 3 ***
Kamara
Cohen
Engram
Mike Williams
Ross
Foreman
Howard
Kupp
Golladay

Really? Engram who is not going to lose his spot for a long time and is getting better and better is gonna be in the same tier as guys like Mike Williams, John Ross, OJ Howard and Foreman?

Are you saying Mike Williams, John Ross, and OJ Howard are not getting better and will lose their spot?

ETA- I didn't put much thought into it and might have Engram too low, I just thought the reasoning was funny.

[Reljac]

Looking through this thread it surprised me how fast people have moved Hunt up their board. Which got me to wonder:

How many people that are currently ranking Hunt as the #1 overall rookie are trying to trade Fournette (or Mixon, or Davis, or CMC, or Cook) to get him? Are the trade offer out, and what were the results?

Just curious.

I own Mixon & McCaffrey in one league. I'd trade either straight up for Hunt. I like his running style. Injuries are unpredicatable, but I am confident by the end of the year, Hunt will be the higher ranked player.

Reljac, I'd give it a shot. Make the offer. You never know what the Hunt owner is thinking.
If you do, would you share the response?

Both offers were declined without comment within 12 hours and no counters. I doubt any Hunt owners are realistically going to move him for any other RB in this year class at the moment.

[Reljac]

Are you saying Mike Williams, John Ross, and OJ Howard are not getting better and will lose their spot?

ETA- I didn't put much thought into it and might have Engram too low, I just thought the reasoning was funny.

Every rookie report I read indicated that Engram would have the best Fantasy year of the three TEs this season. I'm not sure anything we are seeing is a suprise with him compared to Njoku & OJ Howard. Given that we had that knowledge pre-draft, I don't understand how 40yards receiving per game is going to drastically alter the ranking of the three TEs.

[spider321]

Are you saying Mike Williams, John Ross, and OJ Howard are not getting better and will lose their spot?

ETA- I didn't put much thought into it and might have Engram too low, I just thought the reasoning was funny.

Every rookie report I read indicated that Engram would have the best Fantasy year of the three TEs this season. I'm not sure anything we are seeing is a suprise with him compared to Njoku & OJ Howard. Given that we had that knowledge pre-draft, I don't understand how 40yards receiving per game is going to drastically alter the ranking of the three TEs.

Looking at the stat sheet is not gong to change your opinion on Engram as much as watching him play is.

[Reljac]

Looking at the stat sheet is not gong to change your opinion on Engram as much as watching him play is.

I've watched him play plenty. He's doing exactly what I expected him to do. If he's shocking you, maybe you should learn to scout better.

[spider321]

Looking at the stat sheet is not gong to change your opinion on Engram as much as watching him play is.

I've watched him play plenty. He's doing exactly what I expected him to do. If he's shocking you, maybe you should learn to scout better.

Lol