Illegal rosters - 2017
Moderator: TrueDawg
Illegal rosters - 2017
New Jersey Dirty Birds are over the roster limit....24 hours to resolve.
- jimscafs25
- Starter
- Posts: 714
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 2:54 pm
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
I believe Knick Knack has an illegal roster. I don't believe Will fuller is eligible for our IR.
- jimscafs25
- Starter
- Posts: 714
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 2:54 pm
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Also, what is the penalty for keepung an illegal roster for over 24 hours? I could not locate in the league rules page.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Why wouldn't Fuller be eligible for IR? I thought we changed that rule?
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Because he hasn't officially been designated to any list, which is fine, I have no objection to the rules being enforced strictly as written. I'd even advocate for such; however, it is frustrating to seem them enforced strictly sometimes and very loosely others.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Well that rule needs tweaked, let's call it "the common sense rule" Damm guy is out three months, one should be able to put him on IR. I know different thread, but I kept looking at your roster saying how come he hasn't put Fuller on IR...Now I knowXulu Bak wrote: ↑Wed Aug 09, 2017 2:59 pm Because he hasn't officially been designated to any list, which is fine, I have no objection to the rules being enforced strictly as written. I'd even advocate for such; however, it is frustrating to seem them enforced strictly sometimes and very loosely others.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
I'm curious why they still haven't done something with him. Maybe some weird technicality with the timing of the injury or something? I mean, it's a broken collarbone, second opinion not really necessary on this one. He's gonna be out 2-3 months, baring any setbacks, seems pretty obvious that he should go on IR, with the possibility of bringing back two players now.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Yeah that'll be easy to enforce and won't result in ANY complaining. What's "common sense" to some people is "cheating" to others.
Should I be able to put Andrew Luck on IR? Devontae Booker? Should SMTM be able to put Jordan Reed or Teddy Bridgewater on IR?
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Luck would make more sense than retired players. Fuller would make more sense than Luck. I wonder if it might not make more sense for our IR to be independent of the NFL's, but with similar rules/restrictions.
That aside, at least three teams have had illegal rosters since Monday. Since we're well outside the 48-hour window, I trust penalties will start being assessed.
That aside, at least three teams have had illegal rosters since Monday. Since we're well outside the 48-hour window, I trust penalties will start being assessed.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Dont be shy...name names.
I frankly don't have time to babysit everyone's roster to make sure they're all legal at all times.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
TJ Logan is also in this same boat....out a while but not officially placed on any injured list yet.
I activated him because he's not eligible for IR. His roster is still legal.
I activated him because he's not eligible for IR. His roster is still legal.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
By the way, HC Rebels didn't really have an illegal roster...I mistakenly entered Tannehill's contract as no-bonus. I've fixed that and his roster is legal (and really always was). That was my fault.
Re: Illegal rosters - 2017
Ahh. That was one I thought was illegal. TJ Logan was another. That just leaves TDU.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests