1.4 CMC vs Cook non PPR

[Knox Steel Curtain]

I have picks 2 and 4 in upcoming non ppr draft. Assuming Fournett is gone, I am going Davis at 2. At 4 I was going CMC but lately been thinking Cook might be the better option. Just wanted to get some opinions on this.

I also have offer of 1.7 and 1.9 for this pick . I have Kelce so not huge need for Howard. In non ppr, Perine seems to have a lot of value.

Should I stay at 4 or make move? Leaning towards staying with the pick at 4.

[Goddard]

Stay at 4 and take Cook.

[curtisn16]

Cook > CMC

[PRESS50]

Cook easily

[Chris10385]

stay at 4.....mixon if he is there.

[Novacane]

There has been a lot of Cooks love on the forum the last couple of days. Give me CMC easily over Cook, even in a non-PPR league.

[pocylpse]

I would stay at 4.

Mixon>Cook>CMC

Cook is being desperately undervalued because of combine and situation. He should rise above it all. He had a horrible offensive line at Florida State and was a stud.

[pierson242]

Take Davis if Fournette goes 1st. If Davis goes 1st take Mixon

At 1.04 take Mixon if he falls otherwise if Davis Fournette or Mixon falls take them otherwise take cook

Basically ranking them
1. Davis
2. Mixon
3. Fournette
4. Cook

[Maximus891]

stay at 4.....mixon if he is there.

This, if gone then Cook

[0crush83]

Take Davis if Fournette goes 1st. If Davis goes 1st take Mixon

At 1.04 take Mixon if he falls otherwise if Davis Fournette or Mixon falls take them otherwise take cook

Basically ranking them
1. Davis
2. Mixon
3. Fournette
4. Cook

^exactly what he said

[schiewerma21]

Mccaffrey for me. I agree cook lovers poking their tails up again. Guy has been a trainwreck throughout the process but I do appreciate the blind resiliance!!!

also I hate mccaffrey in standard. I would wait til draft day and trade out. I think this is really bad when I truly look at it. Outside of fournette Davis and Mixon I don't want anyone in standard.

[Goddard]

Mccaffrey for me. I agree cook lovers poking their tails up again. Guy has been a trainwreck throughout the process but I do appreciate the blind resiliance!!!

also I hate mccaffrey in standard. I would wait til draft day and trade out. I think this is really bad when I truly look at it. Outside of fournette Davis and Mixon I don't want anyone in standard.

Why do CMC lovers always get offended and have to be so condescending when others don't pick their guy?

[Shoreline Steamers]

I don't hate McCaffrey as a player, but want no part of him in standard. I don't see him carrying in short yardage/goal line, and that's where a lot of RB value lies in the format. I've made the "smaller RB" mistake a few times even though I play standard with the most recent blunder being Duke Johnson. I'm no longer going down that path.

If you could land two of Fournette/Mixon/Cook in that order with picks #2 and #4 I think you'd be doing just fine. However I also agree that if Davis is there at #2 he's the pick, and you take whichever RB is left at #4. Don't trade down from #4 unless you're rebuilding, have a lot of dead weight on your roster, or get an amazing package from someone to move up.

[pierson242]

Mccaffrey for me. I agree cook lovers poking their tails up again. Guy has been a trainwreck throughout the process but I do appreciate the blind resiliance!!!

also I hate mccaffrey in standard. I would wait til draft day and trade out. I think this is really bad when I truly look at it. Outside of fournette Davis and Mixon I don't want anyone in standard.

Why do CMC lovers always get offended and have to be so condescending when others don't pick their guy?

Totally agree

[Kramer]

I would stay at 4.

Mixon>Cook>CMC

Cook is being desperately undervalued because of combine and situation. He should rise above it all. He had a horrible offensive line at Florida State and was a stud.

This in non-ppr.