Allen Robinson or Amari Cooper

[The Fantasy Feud]

Similar Age. Similar expectations. Who ya got?

[gogobradyarm]

They both have great talent, but I believe Cooper has the better career. Robinson's injury history scares me a bit and the way he always puts his body on the line does not promote good health.

[IBall2]

They both have great talent, but I believe Cooper has the better career. Robinson's injury history scares me a bit and the way he always puts his body on the line does not promote good health.

But didn't cooper have a nagging injury the entire second half of this season? Plus Cooper had foot injuries in his 2013 college season that lasted most of the season (which is similar to what he had this year). Seems like the injury history is closer than some people believe because cooper played through his injures.

The fact that Robinson came back this year with no side effects of his previous foot injury makes me believe this is a non-issue now.

[FantasyFreak]

They both have great talent, but I believe Cooper has the better career. Robinson's injury history scares me a bit and the way he always puts his body on the line does not promote good health.

But didn't cooper have a nagging injury the entire second half of this season? Plus Cooper had foot injuries in his 2013 college season that lasted most of the season (which is similar to what he had this year). Seems like the injury history is closer than some people believe because cooper played through his injures.

The fact that Robinson came back this year with no side effects of his previous foot injury makes me believe this is a non-issue now.

I think it was later in the season. Not a full 2nd half. Yes, he missed a few games in 2013 with a foot injury. He didn't actually miss any time, last season, though, so it was not so significant that it made him miss games. His foot problems certainly aren't in the realm of Julio Jones, who has had surgery on the same foot, twice. I would not put either of them in the injury risk category,at this point, though. I think your point is valid. Cooper and Robinson hold the same injury risk. Yes, Robinson had to be shut down and have surgery (I think), but Cooper has had nagging foot injuries a few different times. Personally I like Cooper in a PPR setting. I think his floor is recognized by most to be high, but I think his ceiling is being under-estimated. I think he can put up 110 plus catches for 1500 plus yard and 10 plus TD's.

[captain caveman]

I'll take Robinson for now just for the fact he lit it up last year. Cooper could do it this year though because the skill is there. Both qb's on their team play the same. They have roughly the same ADP right now too. Coin flip.

[Dynasty DeLorean]

Very close. I feel like Cooper is safer somehow but I couldn't really say why.

[Valhalla]

Very close. I feel like Cooper is safer somehow but I couldn't really say why.

I go Cooper and it's pretty easy for me. Carr is just plain safer than Bortles long term, IMO. Not a Bortles fan

[shackleford42]

I went Cooper as well. I trust Cooper's hands and Carr's arm more than Bortles.

[jaykay22]

Very close. I feel like Cooper is safer somehow but I couldn't really say why.

I go Cooper and it's pretty easy for me. Carr is just plain safer than Bortles long term, IMO. Not a Bortles fan

Same. I love both WR's, but I have no faith in Bortles long term.

[DynoScout]

I'll take Robinson. I feel he will consistently score more TDs than Cooper.

[CrimeLord]

I think they're so close it's like splitting hairs. Perhaps capitalize on that if you have someone who wants to swap. If you own Cooper and they want to give you ARob, ask for ARob and a piece or vice versa.

[Unicorn92]

Cooper i take cooper

[Steelersfan]

Splitting hairs here but give me Cooper.