Michael Crabtree or Jonathan Stewart

[toddbamford]

Who is more valuable? Trying to determine for a possible trade in a PPR league.

[Away Team]

Pretty damn even. I'd prefer Crabtree, after a bounce back season in an ascending offense.

[g30rry]

I prefer Crabtree and it's not really close for me, unless you have no other options at RB. Stewart is less reliable and has limited goal-line chances even for a supposed every-down back (when healthy). Like the last poster said, Crabtree had a bounce-back season, which makes sense because the season before that was when he was still recovering from injury. If you look at the big picture of his production, his value should hold steady or even increase, if you need to sell later.