D.Murray or L.Miller?

[Jay]

Who do you like best as a #2 RB?

[Chandler Bing]

Miller

[holy_stromboli]

Miller

[dynastyninja]

Murray

[sloth8u]

if both are healthy, i take murray. we dont know how miller will be used or if his body can hold up. miller is younger and the unknown always intrigues me about him, so i may lean miller with all we know about both players.

[dynastyninja]

if both are healthy, i take murray. we dont know how miller will be used or if his body can hold up. miller is younger and the unknown always intrigues me about him, so i may lean miller with all we know about both players.

Here's a question. What about Murray and Randle or Miller and whoever his handcuff is?

[Never Veto1]

I actaully had a trade offer involving both these players just last week.

I was offered Murray for Miller and the 1.01

I obviously said no, but apparently some people are that high on Murray

[MR ROURKE]

I'd rather own a healthy Murray, but Murray will likely never be healthy. I think it's a push.

[Chris_R]

I'd rather own a healthy Murray, but Murray will likely never be healthy. I think it's a push.

That's what I was gonna say, if we are taking health out I'm taking Murray easily but I really don't see him playing 16 games this year or any season so I have to take that into consideration. I know he hasn't racked up a ton of TD's but he's the feature back in a very explosive offense that at least will give him a bunch of opportunities. I think he'd be a 1200 yard rusher with 500 receiving yards and 7-8 TD's consistently playing 16 games and Dallas loves feeding him the rock. But for now I prefer Miller because he's a bit younger and they are both similiar in my rankings so I want to gamble on Miller. I owned both on the team in my sig, and when I missed out on Christine Michael I preferred to use Murray to get him and Miller isn't going anywhere.


My hope for Murray is that he can play 14 games, and the 2 games he misses are not in the fantasy playoffs. I'd sign up with him as my starter all day long if I knew it was closer to 14 but that would be a career high games played for him.

[DonBrazi]

Is Miller the pinnacle of health? Seems to me like you gotta say their health is a push and a non-factor in this debate. That being the case, you HAVE to side with the guy we've seen do something on the field, right?

[Titus Young's Lawyer]

Miller

[lifetimelaker]

Murray

Miller aint dont nothing yet