Michael Thomas or Tyreek Hill?

[Jaydonley37]

Michael Thomas or Tyreek Hill? .5 ppr

[Jigga94]

I have the top guys as Nuk, Tyreek, OBJ, Adams, MT

Nuk is so solid it's crazy. Tyreek has started running better routes and has shown he can win a jump ball or 2. Oh and he has game breaking speed. If there was no sideline, he'd score every play by outrunning everyone. He's that exciting to watch.

OBJ is still 3rd for me. Ridiculous talent but I am a little nervous about him. He's still able to out up numbers with Eli though so he's great.

Adams and MT are both great talents in great situations. I'm nervous about both after their QB retire. Brees is getting close and I worry about MTs future a tad. That being said, his routes and hands are bar none. There was some crazy stats (around week 10?) about him not dropping any pass and converting 100% of 3rd downs or something. I'm butchering it, but it was a very impressive metric.

[Smoking Guns]

Even to me but the tie breaker is Mahomes throwing to Hill for the next several years .i will probably be in the minority here but when WR’s are close give me the best QB.

[murphysxm]

With it being .5 PPR I like Hill slightly better short term, but a lot better long term

[Huh]

Nuk did not drop a ball this year. I think I would shop them both and take which ever fetches the bigger pot.

[Gator Sens]

Based on QB ages of Brees and Mahomes, I would lean to the Hill side. Not sure you could go wrong either way though