Aaron Jones vs Rashaad Penny vs Derrius Guice

[ajf235]

How would you rank Penny, Guice and Jones in half PPR based on who you think will score the most points from 2019-2020?

[Titans95]

Guice, Jones, Penny

[FantasyFreakGuru]

Jones, Guice (can easily move up),






Penny

[FantasyFreak]

This is tough. Penny has looked good in limited action, has proven he can be an explosive playmaker in the NFL, BUT will his team use him? I have him above Guice on talent, have done before this season, and still do based on the fact he has clearly shown his game can translate. Guice has had knee problems for 2 straight years, AND suffered complications to his ACL surgery. He may not have the competition that Penny has, and thus more opportunity to score points. Jones has not proven he can stay healthy, but has proven he can produce. The Packers will have a new staff next year, so who knows how that shakes out.

[Titans95]

This is tough. Penny has looked good in limited action, has proven he can be an explosive playmaker in the NFL, BUT will his team use him? I have him above Guice on talent, have done before this season, and still do based on the fact he has clearly shown his game can translate. Guice has had knee problems for 2 straight years, AND suffered complications to his ACL surgery. He may not have the competition that Penny has, and thus more opportunity to score points. Jones has not proven he can stay healthy, but has proven he can produce. The Packers will have a new staff next year, so who knows how that shakes out.

I had Guice just ever so slightly ahead of Penny from a talent standpoint but I had Penny ahead of guice in my rankings due to situation....funny how things change so fast, now I love Guice's situation 1000x more than Penny's, only concern is like you said....he knee issues.

I love Penny but I just can't see Carson going away, I expect both of them to consistently get 10-12 carries per game with Penny taking the lead in the passing game but Carson getting the goal line carries.....AKA fantasy nightmare lol

[FantasyFreak]

This is tough. Penny has looked good in limited action, has proven he can be an explosive playmaker in the NFL, BUT will his team use him? I have him above Guice on talent, have done before this season, and still do based on the fact he has clearly shown his game can translate. Guice has had knee problems for 2 straight years, AND suffered complications to his ACL surgery. He may not have the competition that Penny has, and thus more opportunity to score points. Jones has not proven he can stay healthy, but has proven he can produce. The Packers will have a new staff next year, so who knows how that shakes out.

I had Guice just ever so slightly ahead of Penny from a talent standpoint but I had Penny ahead of guice in my rankings due to situation....funny how things change so fast, now I love Guice's situation 1000x more than Penny's, only concern is like you said....he knee issues.

I love Penny but I just can't see Carson going away, I expect both of them to consistently get 10-12 carries per game with Penny taking the lead in the passing game but Carson getting the goal line carries.....AKA fantasy nightmare lol

I am wondering what is going to happen at QB in Washington now. Hoping Guice can stay healthy, but I have a bad feeling about his ability to do so. As for Penny, I really hope they utilize him in the passing game next year. A good game against Arizona this week would be nice to see. Carson is certainly a concern. I thought Penny had a great situation, funny. Funny how people were worried about the offensive line, but they have been great. It was Carson that ended up being the concern for Penny, not the OL.