Alvin Kamara vs. Michael Thomas

[waynesworld1234]

Title says it all. Who would you rather take as the cornerstone of your future?

[Forza_Azzurri]

Kamara, because I think he’ll transition post-Brees better than Thomas.

[AussieMate]

Thomas, but only because I'm incapable of hitting on a receiver whilst have a good history on RBS.
Seriously, anyone got a clue on how to scout a top WR?

[Titans95]

Thomas, but only because I'm incapable of hitting on a receiver whilst have a good history on RBS.
Seriously, anyone got a clue on how to scout a top WR?

I think it's a bit harder and that's why WR's typically have "more value" that RB's. Not just because of longevity. If you look at all the top WR's that have been drafted in the years following 2014 class vs the Rb's its almost childsplay to hit on a good RB compared to a WR.


However, give me Kamara

[Titans95]

Kamara, because I think he’ll transition post-Brees better than Thomas.

This, Kamara will most likely benefit from a Teddy Bridgewater type checking down to him 5-10 times a game.

[Mjvb5]

Thomas, but only because I'm incapable of hitting on a receiver whilst have a good history on RBS.
Seriously, anyone got a clue on how to scout a top WR?

I think it's a bit harder and that's why WR's typically have "more value" that RB's. Not just because of longevity. If you look at all the top WR's that have been drafted in the years following 2014 class vs the Rb's its almost childsplay to hit on a good RB compared to a WR.


However, give me Kamara

Lol amen, hey this RB was drafted highly(top 3 rounds)... 50/50 odds at worst
Still though give me kamara

[Duke Nuk’em]

Kamara, because I think he’ll transition post-Brees better than Thomas.

I actually think that Brees and his ability to spread the ball to anyone who's open and with his range helps Kamara more than Thomas. Against most teams the field is so spread leaving gaping holes everywhere.

Thomas for me, but it is by the narrowist of margins.