Hopkins vs M. Thomas

[BHerm24]

Who has more for value the rest of this season and moving forward past this year?

[Tyrober]

Talent level and production are very similar. Nuk is slightly older but also tied to a franchise QB which breaks any ties between them for me. Brady and Brees seem ageless but they arent. Give me Nuk

[Goddard]

Hopkins is less than a year older. That shouldn't really be an issue when comparing the two. I also think he's the more talented player and in the better long-term situation. Give me Nuk.

[Mjvb5]

similar value to me going forward edge to Thomas this year but Hopkins moving forward

[Blueboy]

Nuk. He's my top WR, Thomas is "only" a top 5 WR.

[Titans95]

I love them both and its blasphemous to consider either one outside the top 5 but I don't think age is a factor when Nuk is 26 and MT is 25. Brees is 39 though and Watson is 23....I also think Nuk is quite a bit more talented. He's been absolutely elite regardless of QB, we haven't been able to test that with MT considering he has arguably the most accurate QB of all time.

[Duke Nuk’em]

I love them both and its blasphemous to consider either one outside the top 5 but I don't think age is a factor when Nuk is 26 and MT is 25. Brees is 39 though and Watson is 23....I also think Nuk is quite a bit more talented. He's been absolutely elite regardless of QB, we haven't been able to test that with MT considering he has arguably the most accurate QB of all time.

agreed

[Ice]

Hopkins. He is my top WR. Long term outlook looks much better due to QB situation. The Saints look to be in transition to a much more balanced attack especially in the red zone.