Wilkins vs miller vs smith

[toppthree]

Which rookie to draft in dynasty

[Ice]

Miller by a wide margin.

[Goddard]

Miller

Smith
Wilkins

[Orenthal Shames]

Miller

Smith
Wilkins

*Ding ding ding*

[FantasyFreak]

Wilkins doesn't belong in the conversation with the other two. I actually prefer Tre'quan over Miller. I acidentally voted Miller.

[Titans95]

I think Wilkins does deserve to be in the conversation with Smith because if he performs well in week 1 he may steal the job outright from Mack. Miller on the other hand has no business being in this conversation. He's a back end 1st round pick, these other two are early 3rds at best

[FantasyFreak]

I think Wilkins does deserve to be in the conversation with Smith because if he performs well in week 1 he may steal the job outright from Mack. Miller on the other hand has no business being in this conversation. He's a back end 1st round pick, these other two are early 3rds at best

Disagree. Tre'quan should be a 2nd round pick IMO. Not sure how 24 guys go ahead of a day 2 pick that has done well so far. Wilkins isn't even guaranteed touches ahead of C-Mike, and has been running on 2 teams at best in the preseason. I think there is almost zero chance he takes the job week 1, even with a good performance. Wilkins is a 5th round pick while the other two are day 2 picks. Smith had drawn rave reviews in training camp and has done well with his opportunities in preseason. Per Cecil Lammey, there are people he has talked to within the Saints building that view Tre'quan as their number 2 WR right now.

[Titans95]

I think Wilkins does deserve to be in the conversation with Smith because if he performs well in week 1 he may steal the job outright from Mack. Miller on the other hand has no business being in this conversation. He's a back end 1st round pick, these other two are early 3rds at best

Disagree. Tre'quan should be a 2nd round pick IMO. Not sure how 24 guys go ahead of a day 2 pick that has done well so far. Wilkins isn't even guaranteed touches ahead of C-Mike, and has been running on 2 teams at best in the preseason. I think there is almost zero chance he takes the job week 1, even with a good performance. Wilkins is a 5th round pick while the other two are day 2 picks. Smith had drawn rave reviews in training camp and has done well with his opportunities in preseason. Per Cecil Lammey, there are people he has talked to within the Saints building that view Tre'quan as their number 2 WR right now.

Only time will tell and luckily we don't have to wait long. FINALLY FOOTBALL!!!!

[FantasyFreak]

I think Wilkins does deserve to be in the conversation with Smith because if he performs well in week 1 he may steal the job outright from Mack. Miller on the other hand has no business being in this conversation. He's a back end 1st round pick, these other two are early 3rds at best

Disagree. Tre'quan should be a 2nd round pick IMO. Not sure how 24 guys go ahead of a day 2 pick that has done well so far. Wilkins isn't even guaranteed touches ahead of C-Mike, and has been running on 2 teams at best in the preseason. I think there is almost zero chance he takes the job week 1, even with a good performance. Wilkins is a 5th round pick while the other two are day 2 picks. Smith had drawn rave reviews in training camp and has done well with his opportunities in preseason. Per Cecil Lammey, there are people he has talked to within the Saints building that view Tre'quan as their number 2 WR right now.

Only time will tell and luckily we don't have to wait long. FINALLY FOOTBALL!!!!

I know. Speculating gets boring pretty quickly. I'm so ready for some real football to start.