Parker vs Crowder

[Jcedwards]

I have a guy interested in trading for 1 of them and I'm not sure which one to keep or whether to just keep both. Guy is wanting to trade a 2019 2nd straight up for one of them. I have the depth to get rid of 1 of them, but should I trade either one for a 2nd straight up or keep them both for the depth?

I currently only have 1 pick in 2019 (1st round), so this would help me gain another pick. This pick will probably end up early-mid 2nd. The guy who originally had the pick is rebuilding, so he should finish toward the bottom.

[Ice]

I would not trade either for a future 2nd round pick. That is a horrible offer. I could see trading one for a 2nd if I was on the clock and knew I would get a targeted player but that is laughable right now.

[bawilks]

Probably not either of them. You can definitely get more.

[Jcedwards]

Probably not either of them. You can definitely get more.

Well now he proposed this:

MY Parker and 2020 2nd for
HIS Godwin and 2019 2nd (probably early)

[bawilks]

Nooooooooooo way. I wouldn’t even do parker for Godwin and a 2nd

[Jcedwards]

Nooooooooooo way. I wouldn’t even do parker for Godwin and a 2nd

I might do Godwin and a 2nd for Parker, but I'm going to try and talk him down or I won't do a deal at all.

[Dirty Mike&the Boys]

I don't see anything wrong with the trade... Goodwin put up about 150 pts last year and Parker put up 118. I think I would counter the following just to see if you could swing it in your favor a tad more:

Parker
3rd next yr

Goodwin
2nd next yr

[Jcedwards]

I don't see anything wrong with the trade... Goodwin put up about 150 pts last year and Parker put up 118. I think I would counter the following just to see if you could swing it in your favor a tad more:

Parker
3rd next yr

Goodwin
2nd next yr

It’s for Chris Godwin, not Goodwin. I did talk him down to Godwin and 2019 2nd (probably early) for Parker and 2020 3rd (probably late if my team stays competitive)

[bawilks]

I don’t think you should be adding anything on top of Parker. I don’t think you should even be moving Parker... not for Godwin at least. Seems Parker has a lot more upside than Godwin as long as he stays healthy. Landry is gone now and Tannehill is back. I see Parker being more productive in the long run. If you want Godwin for some reason try to put Crowder back on his place.

Crowder for Godwin and his 2nd

[Ice]

I don't see anything wrong with the trade... Goodwin put up about 150 pts last year and Parker put up 118. I think I would counter the following just to see if you could swing it in your favor a tad more:

Parker
3rd next yr

Goodwin
2nd next yr

It’s for Chris Godwin, not Goodwin. I did talk him down to Godwin and 2019 2nd (probably early) for Parker and 2020 3rd (probably late if my team stays competitive)

This doesn't help you. Parker, as much as some hate has WR1 upside. Godwin has some longer term potential as a WR2 on his own team.

You are not talking him down, despite you thinking you are.

[Jcedwards]

I don't see anything wrong with the trade... Goodwin put up about 150 pts last year and Parker put up 118. I think I would counter the following just to see if you could swing it in your favor a tad more:

Parker
3rd next yr

Goodwin
2nd next yr

It’s for Chris Godwin, not Goodwin. I did talk him down to Godwin and 2019 2nd (probably early) for Parker and 2020 3rd (probably late if my team stays competitive)

This doesn't help you. Parker, as much as some hate has WR1 upside. Godwin has some longer term potential as a WR2 on his own team.

You are not talking him down, despite you thinking you are.

I appreciate the input, but I beg to differ on the talking him down part. He originally asked for Parker and a 2020 2nd for Godwin and 2019 2nd. Then he moved it back to Parker and 2020 3rd. And now the offer is just Parker for Godwin and 2019 2nd.

[Ice]

It’s for Chris Godwin, not Goodwin. I did talk him down to Godwin and 2019 2nd (probably early) for Parker and 2020 3rd (probably late if my team stays competitive)

This doesn't help you. Parker, as much as some hate has WR1 upside. Godwin has some longer term potential as a WR2 on his own team.

You are not talking him down, despite you thinking you are.

I appreciate the input, but I beg to differ on the talking him down part. He originally asked for Parker and a 2020 2nd for Godwin and 2019 2nd. Then he moved it back to Parker and 2020 3rd. And now the offer is just Parker for Godwin and 2019 2nd.

Good luck,

From my perspective you are getting killed in the deal but if you like it go for it.