Joe Mixon, sell or keep

[lukkynumber13]

Easy keep for me . If Mixon was in this class based on talent alone he would be my clear cut #2 and it would be by a fair margin ..

This is one scouts view.

Now that the top tier rookie rbs are housed in new garages, what are thoughts on Mixon versus the rooks?

I have seen in this thread that in regards to the 2018 rookies:

• 1.02 > Mixon

• Mixon > 1.02

To be transparent, I have Mixon and have been offered the 1.02 (PPR).

IMO, the value of the 1.02 has dropped some. Mixon easily over the 1.02 for me.

[Phantom Knight]

Easy keep for me . If Mixon was in this class based on talent alone he would be my clear cut #2 and it would be by a fair margin ..

This is one scouts view.

Now that the top tier rookie rbs are housed in new garages, what are thoughts on Mixon versus the rooks?

I have seen in this thread that in regards to the 2018 rookies:

• 1.02 > Mixon

• Mixon > 1.02

To be transparent, I have Mixon and have been offered the 1.02 (PPR).

IMO, the value of the 1.02 has dropped some. Mixon easily over the 1.02 for me.

Thank you. Since the draft, I no longer have a clear #2. So I no longer value the 1.02 more than the 1.03 and possibly not more than the 1.04 either. Just before the draft, I was about to pull the trigger (sending Mixon for the 1.02) thinking I would prefer Guice to Mixon. While, I like Guice's landing spot, I find myself (buying the hype?) becoming intrigued by 2-3 other backs. You have helped pull me back from the ledge.

[Titans95]

Now that the top tier rookie rbs are housed in new garages, what are thoughts on Mixon versus the rooks?

I have seen in this thread that in regards to the 2018 rookies:

• 1.02 > Mixon

• Mixon > 1.02

To be transparent, I have Mixon and have been offered the 1.02 (PPR).

IMO, the value of the 1.02 has dropped some. Mixon easily over the 1.02 for me.

Thank you. Since the draft, I no longer have a clear #2. So I no longer value the 1.02 more than the 1.03 and possibly not more than the 1.04 either. Just before the draft, I was about to pull the trigger (sending Mixon for the 1.02) thinking I would prefer Guice to Mixon. While, I like Guice's landing spot, I find myself (buying the hype?) becoming intrigued by 2-3 other backs. You have helped pull me back from the ledge.

Honestly I've had Mixon higher than the 1.02 all along but now even more so...Besides for Barkley and Penny there isn't any rookie with a clear path to a larger workload than Mixon. Guice won't step foot on the field on 3rd downs as long as Chris Thompson is healthy, same with chubb, I think there is way to much uncertainty in NE to expect Michel to get the volume or usage he needs to be an RB1, Rojo is in a great spot but he isn't close to the talent level of Mixon