Guice vs. Chubb

[cazzie33]

" I like Chubbs 6.0 YPC in 2017 vs Guices 5.2"

Because they had the same linemen, QB and opportunity and Guice wasn't hurt early in the year ? Do you like Kamara as a runner over Gurley too ?

Apples and Oranges, IMO. Chubb and Guice are very similar in a lot of ways, obviously Gurley and Kamara are not. We are also evaluating college players, while Gurley just had an MVP like season in the NFL, and has shown to be a 3 down workhorse, whereas Kamara has not.

But his YPC He must be better

[FantasyFreak]

" I like Chubbs 6.0 YPC in 2017 vs Guices 5.2"

Because they had the same linemen, QB and opportunity and Guice wasn't hurt early in the year ? Do you like Kamara as a runner over Gurley too ?

Apples and Oranges, IMO. Chubb and Guice are very similar in a lot of ways, obviously Gurley and Kamara are not. We are also evaluating college players, while Gurley just had an MVP like season in the NFL, and has shown to be a 3 down workhorse, whereas Kamara has not.

But his YPC He must be better

I'm not sure that was entirely his point, but I agree circumstances are different. I'm not siding with one or the other, I think he was just saying it was one of the factors of why he liked Chubb more. He had a complete paragraph before that on why he liked Chubb better as well.

[spotxc]

I feel like Michel belongs in this conversation also. All 3 are in competition for 2-4 for me depending on draft capital and landing spots. I believe all 3 are great talents, and waiting to see who gets the best fits. As of now, probably guice, then I can’t decide between Michel and chubb

[Dr. Trades]

I feel like Michel belongs in this conversation also. All 3 are in competition for 2-4 for me depending on draft capital and landing spots. I believe all 3 are great talents, and waiting to see who gets the best fits. As of now, probably guice, then I can’t decide between Michel and chubb

Agree. I go Guice > Chubb > Michel, but they're all close enough that draft will determine how their value will ultimately play out.
In film, I really appreciate Chubb's vision over the others. If he continues to and fully gets back from injury, he has the highest upside imo. But the other two probably have an edge in the receiving department. I'll be very interested to see how we're talking about these three guys compared to each other in 3 years or so.

[Space Cowboy]

I'm going guice regardless at 1.02. Anyone but the patriots.