Keelan Cole vs Treadwell ?

[homer]

Treadwell is a bust. Take Cole cause those Jax Wr's always get hurt

[clarion contrarion]

treadwells 2 best years 21 catches 215 yards ZERO tds
coles 2 best games 13 catches 294 yards 1 TD

draft capital counts for very little if that player proves to be ill fitted to the pro game. Keeping a guy because his value has dropped is the same as riding a stock all the way to zero just because you have already lost $ on paper - great way to lose the rest of your investment. Better to lose 10$ off a 20$ stock than to ride it into chapter 11 just because it already halved .

[hockeyBjj]

Cole > Bologna Sandwich >>>>> Treadwell

[diamonddave]

i drafted treadwell two years ago with a high first-founder and would trade him in a heartbeat for cole. i'd trade him for anyone with a heartbeat for that matter. but since that's not happening, i'm gonna hold him and pray for a third year breakout.

[ArrylT]

i drafted treadwell two years ago with a high first-founder and would trade him in a heartbeat for cole. i'd trade him for anyone with a heartbeat for that matter. but since that's not happening, i'm gonna hold him and pray for a third year breakout.

If I was in a league with you and had Cole and you had Treadwell I'd gladly make that trade.

[mike40]

Dropped Treadwell earlier this season for Cole... No one has picked Treadwell up in my league lol

[ArrylT]

Dropped Treadwell earlier this season for Cole... No one has picked Treadwell up in my league lol

[Maximus891]

I/m taking Treadwell here, going into his 3rd year and hope he breaks out a bit. I don't see him being more then a WR3 on the vikes, but if he can turn it around I want him on my team. I only own him in one league where he sits beind the likes of Hopkins, Evans, Cooper, Hilton and OBJ, so I can wait and see.

Cole played very well when needed but I can see the Jags drafting more WRs with Lee and A Rod rookie contracts coming to an end in March I believe.

Really this is just a coin flip and hope you pick right.

[BigBawseRoss]

Cole by a whole lot. look at what he did his rookie year, its pretty amazing for an UDFA to get 750 yards and he didn't really get steady looks/usage till week 9.

[meineymoe]

I just traded Cole and rookie pick 3.07 for Treadwell and pick 2.09. Neither of them would be starting for me, and I prefer the potential of the former first round pick entering only his third season who is the #3 wr on his team, over the undrafted guy who flashed last season but disappeared in the playoffs, and will be battling for targets with several other options and a probable top rookie wr pick.

Looking forward to seeing how this pans out!

-oo-

[FantasyFreak]

Cole. Treadwell is a bust. Can't hack it at the NFL level. Even if Treadwell somehow gets it together, his upside is very limited. His lack of athleticism prevents him from ever being much of anything more than a WR3, best case scenario IMO. I don't think he ever goes over 180 yards in a game like Cole did last year.

[AussieMate]

I'm usually for waiting, he'll I've waited 4yrs for a player to breakout. Usually you need to see some flash if potential though and Treadwell hasn't shown anything close. To be honest both will prob cone to nothing, but, Cole did help me to the finals so I'm biased.