Lamar Jackson or Guice?

[GoodellsPaycheck]

So Im punting this year, hoping to get the prized Saquon. But it looks like that will be tough in my league since there is someone else that is truly terrible

If im sitting there with the 2nd pick.....should I gamble on Lamar playing well at QB in the NFL. or should I take Guice and hope he proves worthy of the #2 pick

[Go Bucks]

If you only start one QB, then easily Guice. Even if start 2 QB's, I'd lean Guice over any of the QB's unless your QB's suck.

[lukkynumber13]

Even in a start 2 QB, do not take Jackson at 2

[GoodellsPaycheck]

Even in a start 2 QB, do not take Jackson at 2

Is Ridley worth a top 5? Haven't seen much of him

I think there's a big drop off from Barkley but I'm trying to come up with a contingency plan

[lukkynumber13]

Even in a start 2 QB, do not take Jackson at 2

Is Ridley worth a top 5? Haven't seen much of him

I think there's a big drop off from Barkley but I'm trying to come up with a contingency plan

Too early to think it's only going to be a tier of 1. What if Guice gets drafted in round 1 by Indy or Oakland or Washington? What if Ridley, Kirk, St. Brown, or Sutton get drafted top 5?

[BigBawseRoss]

come back in 11 months and see what people say

[senska11]

Jackson won't even be the best pro QB in the class, so definitely not him.

[Space Cowboy]

Guice is an all world talent and a better RB than Fournette.

[onetwothree]

Should be a deep QB class. Jackson still has a long way to go. Guice now and for the foreseeable future.

[Goddard]

Surprised Jackson is in the same conversation as Guice.

[GoodellsPaycheck]

Guice is an all world talent and a better RB than Fournette.

Is this true? What am I missing about Guice?

Barkley easily looks better than him, and Fournette's eye test passes with flying colors. How would you stack up Guice vs Mixon/Cook/Zeke/Gurley and what makes him so good?