Crabtree v Abdullah

[OCPunisher]

Team 1 below has one too many receivers and one too few backs. Should I make this swap?

[lukkynumber13]

Yes, as long as the Abdullah side adds at LEAST a First

[OCPunisher]

Yes, as long as the Abdullah side adds at LEAST a First

That bad, eh? They were pretty similarly ranked on this site, and my league starts two backs instead of one, which would push a back like Abdullah further up the list. Add in the Zeke suspension and the fact that Crabtree is my 5th WR, and it made sense at the time. I take it Abdullah's injury history is bad enough to trump all that?

[lukkynumber13]

Yes, as long as the Abdullah side adds at LEAST a First

That bad, eh? They were pretty similarly ranked on this site, and my league starts two backs instead of one, which would push a back like Abdullah further up the list. Add in the Zeke suspension and the fact that Crabtree is my 5th WR, and it made sense at the time. I take it Abdullah's injury history is bad enough to trump all that?

Yup. Abdullah is one season away from becoming Dion Lewis, whereas Crabtree is an annual WR2

[Goddard]

Value wise it's close, but I prefer Crabtree as well.

[millworkguy]

Just because they will not see your lineup doesnt mean you give away value like that. I like abdullah, and still see you getting a pick back in that deal. Nut je is much more of a risk/reward play then Crabtree (and many would argue risk more then reward)