McCaffery or Davis?

This is the spot for player-to-player comparisons.
User avatar
Dyno_7
Role Player
Role Player
Posts: 462
Joined: Sun Jan 15, 2017 8:49 pm

McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Dyno_7 » Sat Jul 22, 2017 7:48 pm

This is for my sig team. 10 team, Non-PPR.

I have the 1.01 & 1.04 and another owner has the 1.02 & 1.03. We've since compared notes and the first 3 picked will be Mixon, Fournette & Cook.

This leaves me with CMC or Davis at the 1.04. This is a non-ppr league, so my gut is telling me Davis even though I don't need anymore WR's. Another option is the owner at 1.08 needs WR's pretty badly. If I offer up the 1.04 to him, what would you ask for in return? I was thinking his pick at 1.08 + his 1st in 2018, but I don't know if that's too much or too little.

What would you do?
TEAMS 1&2: 10tm. Non-PPR +IDP.
Starters: 1QB-2RB-3WR-1TE-1K-2DL-1EDR-3LB-3DB

TEAM 1:
QB: C.Wentz, P.Rivers, J.Rosen, L.Jackson.
RB: J.Mixon, L.Fournette, J.Howard, D.Williams
WR: O.BeckhamJr, M.Thomas, S.Diggs, J.Smith-Schuster, S.Watkins, C.Godwin, C.Sutton.
TE: Z.Ertz, M.Gesicki, G.Kittle.
DL: D.Hunter, D.Barnett, C.Jones.
EDR: H.Landry.
LB: M.Jack, Z.Cunningham, A.Williamson, L.Vander Esch, C.Littleton.
DB: R.Jones, B.McDougald, S.Williams.

TEAM 2:
QB: D.Watson.
RB: D.Cook, A.Kamara, J.Mixon, C.Hyde, N.Chubb, A.Jones.
WR: A.Cooper, M.Thomas, J.Smith-Schuster, J.Gordon, M.Williams, K.Golladay, C.Godwin, C.Kirk.
TE: E.Engram, D.Njoku, D.Goedert.
DL: K.Mack, D.Hunter, D.Ware
EDR: V.Miller
LB: T.Smith, M.Jack, D.Jones, Z.Cunningham, T.Edmunds, L.Vander Esch.
DB: B.Baker, D.James, C.Geathers.

User avatar
dlf4lyfe
Pro Bowler
Pro Bowler
Posts: 1397
Joined: Wed Aug 21, 2013 10:48 am

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby dlf4lyfe » Sat Jul 22, 2017 9:51 pm

I'd say that sounds like collusion right there :lol: :wink: .

Mixon or Fournette at 1.01 and trade back to 1.08. I think that's a fair starting point even tho it's asking a lot. Cuz the next offer wil be for 1.08 & 2018 2nd.

I am eying the 1.04 in my draft and I would not do anything more than 1.08 & 2018 2nd. Would much prefer a 3rd tho obviously.
10 team | 10 Keepers | .5 ppr | QB | RBx2 | WRx2 | RB/WR/TE | WR/TE | K | D/ST

QB: Burrow | Prescott
RB: Chubb | Dobbins | Sanders | Edwards-Helaire | Patterson | Edmonds | Henderson | Edwards | Benjamin
WR/TE: Moore | London | Kelce | Cooks | Lockett | Lazard | Parker | Jones

User avatar
Goddard
GOAT
GOAT
Posts: 27771
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2017 9:21 am

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Goddard » Sat Jul 22, 2017 10:31 pm

This is a new one. It's usually CMC vs one of the other RBs. I prefer Davis between the two.

User avatar
Dyno_7
Role Player
Role Player
Posts: 462
Joined: Sun Jan 15, 2017 8:49 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Dyno_7 » Sat Jul 22, 2017 10:40 pm

Goddard wrote: Sat Jul 22, 2017 10:31 pm This is a new one. It's usually CMC vs one of the other RBs. I prefer Davis between the two.
I'm going with Mixon just because he's my guy. The other owner just isn't sold on CMC, so he's going with Cook. It's a standard scoring league, so I wasn't sure if that tilted the scales away from CMC a little. I like both players pretty equally, that's why I'm kinda torn. I could use a 5th RB for depth, but Davis (in many projections) is the concensus #1. Figured I'd ask the forum their thoughts.
Last edited by Dyno_7 on Sat Jul 22, 2017 10:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
TEAMS 1&2: 10tm. Non-PPR +IDP.
Starters: 1QB-2RB-3WR-1TE-1K-2DL-1EDR-3LB-3DB

TEAM 1:
QB: C.Wentz, P.Rivers, J.Rosen, L.Jackson.
RB: J.Mixon, L.Fournette, J.Howard, D.Williams
WR: O.BeckhamJr, M.Thomas, S.Diggs, J.Smith-Schuster, S.Watkins, C.Godwin, C.Sutton.
TE: Z.Ertz, M.Gesicki, G.Kittle.
DL: D.Hunter, D.Barnett, C.Jones.
EDR: H.Landry.
LB: M.Jack, Z.Cunningham, A.Williamson, L.Vander Esch, C.Littleton.
DB: R.Jones, B.McDougald, S.Williams.

TEAM 2:
QB: D.Watson.
RB: D.Cook, A.Kamara, J.Mixon, C.Hyde, N.Chubb, A.Jones.
WR: A.Cooper, M.Thomas, J.Smith-Schuster, J.Gordon, M.Williams, K.Golladay, C.Godwin, C.Kirk.
TE: E.Engram, D.Njoku, D.Goedert.
DL: K.Mack, D.Hunter, D.Ware
EDR: V.Miller
LB: T.Smith, M.Jack, D.Jones, Z.Cunningham, T.Edmunds, L.Vander Esch.
DB: B.Baker, D.James, C.Geathers.

User avatar
Dyno_7
Role Player
Role Player
Posts: 462
Joined: Sun Jan 15, 2017 8:49 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Dyno_7 » Sat Jul 22, 2017 10:44 pm

dlf4lyfe wrote: Sat Jul 22, 2017 9:51 pm I'd say that sounds like collusion right there :lol: :wink: .

Mixon or Fournette at 1.01 and trade back to 1.08. I think that's a fair starting point even tho it's asking a lot. Cuz the next offer wil be for 1.08 & 2018 2nd.

I am eying the 1.04 in my draft and I would not do anything more than 1.08 & 2018 2nd. Would much prefer a 3rd tho obviously.
Hahaha! :shh:

He's my nemesis, so there's definitely no collusion. But, we're close to our draft he just wanted to know who I was leaning toward for 1.01. Since I can't do anything about his 2 & 3 picks, he let me know who he liked at those spots. He swept me last year, so I have to return the favor. Lol
TEAMS 1&2: 10tm. Non-PPR +IDP.
Starters: 1QB-2RB-3WR-1TE-1K-2DL-1EDR-3LB-3DB

TEAM 1:
QB: C.Wentz, P.Rivers, J.Rosen, L.Jackson.
RB: J.Mixon, L.Fournette, J.Howard, D.Williams
WR: O.BeckhamJr, M.Thomas, S.Diggs, J.Smith-Schuster, S.Watkins, C.Godwin, C.Sutton.
TE: Z.Ertz, M.Gesicki, G.Kittle.
DL: D.Hunter, D.Barnett, C.Jones.
EDR: H.Landry.
LB: M.Jack, Z.Cunningham, A.Williamson, L.Vander Esch, C.Littleton.
DB: R.Jones, B.McDougald, S.Williams.

TEAM 2:
QB: D.Watson.
RB: D.Cook, A.Kamara, J.Mixon, C.Hyde, N.Chubb, A.Jones.
WR: A.Cooper, M.Thomas, J.Smith-Schuster, J.Gordon, M.Williams, K.Golladay, C.Godwin, C.Kirk.
TE: E.Engram, D.Njoku, D.Goedert.
DL: K.Mack, D.Hunter, D.Ware
EDR: V.Miller
LB: T.Smith, M.Jack, D.Jones, Z.Cunningham, T.Edmunds, L.Vander Esch.
DB: B.Baker, D.James, C.Geathers.

User avatar
Kramer
MVP
MVP
Posts: 2839
Joined: Mon May 23, 2016 5:07 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Kramer » Sun Jul 23, 2017 12:30 am

Fournette for the top pick easily over the rest of the players for me. Even more so when it's non PPR. Then Davis over CMC easily at pick 4.
10 team SF .5ppr-QB,2RB,3WR,TE,Flex,SF,Def (30 spots)
QB: Allen, AR, Brissett
RB: Mixon,Barkley,Rhamondre,Foreman
WR: Deebo,Adams,Jeudy, Devonta,Nuk
TE: Knox,Chig, Woods, Ferguson
2023 picks: 2, 3, 6, 8, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 18, 19, 20
2024 picks: 3 2nds
2025 picks: 3 2nds

pokerface40
All Pro
All Pro
Posts: 1768
Joined: Sun Mar 22, 2015 11:27 am

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby pokerface40 » Sun Jul 23, 2017 5:27 am

Kramer wrote: Sun Jul 23, 2017 12:30 am Fournette for the top pick easily over the rest of the players for me. Even more so when it's non PPR. Then Davis over CMC easily at pick 4.
What he said.

User avatar
Splinx
Practice Squad
Practice Squad
Posts: 123
Joined: Mon Jun 20, 2016 10:54 am

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Splinx » Sun Jul 23, 2017 7:04 am

Davis...easily! 👍🏼
12 Team Dynasty League
QB - Cousins, Dalton, Bradford
RB - J. Hill, L. Murray, D. Cook, J. Mixon, M. Breida (TS)
WR - A. Cooper, J. Nelson, B. Cooks, C. Meredith, C. Coleman, Sharpe, Treadwell (TS), M. Williams (TS)
TE - Eifert, Henry, Tye
DL - A. Donald, D Hunter, Spence (TS), Rankins (TS), D. Barnett
LB - J. Collins, Perryman, Kwon, J. Smith (TS)
DB - J Addae, B Jones, Amerson

User avatar
IBall2
All Pro
All Pro
Posts: 1571
Joined: Thu Oct 30, 2014 1:28 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby IBall2 » Sun Jul 23, 2017 8:17 am

I'm in a similar situation in my league. I own picks 1.01 1.02 and 1.04 while the league champion owns pick 1.03 and it's a 0.3 PPR league. I'm leaning towards picking Fournette/Mixon at 1 and 2. I think the owner of the 1.03 wants to pick an RB because he's stacked at WR. I'm hoping Davis falls to me at 1.04.

sms
Practice Squad
Practice Squad
Posts: 126
Joined: Sat May 25, 2013 4:03 am

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby sms » Sun Jul 23, 2017 10:45 am

I think Fournette and Davis are the two best players in this draft. I would snag Fournette at 1.01 then Davis at 1.04. The scoring favors taking a RB. If Mixon is your guy, go with him, but Davis should be your next pick if he is available. Davis will be the best player on the board. McCaffery will be depth just like Davis, only Davis is a better player in this format.

cazzie33
All Pro
All Pro
Posts: 1553
Joined: Sat Jun 17, 2017 2:37 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby cazzie33 » Sun Jul 23, 2017 10:56 am

Looking@ your roster you need every RB you can get.

Plus maybe I am wrong but it doesn't appear the decision is yours to make. You get the guy that's left @ 1.04 and be happy with your haul. You can't lose :thumbup:

If the 1.08 guy is wanting Davis then I wouldn't take less than his 2018 1st . Corey is the consensus#1 WR in the draft that landed in a great situation. A 2nd rd pick next year is likely spare parts. To get the best positional player in a draft not to mention one that has the profile to be a WR #1 doesn't come along often.

Number 8 is a crapshoot for opportunity this year and a serious drop off from Davis. If this other team makes playoffs then you're probably looking at a similar situation next year. I was in dire need of depth and traded the 1.05 for 1.09 &Tyreek. The other guy wanted Dalvin bad so we both were happy. I traded the 1.09 for 1.10 & 3.04 to a team wanting J. Ross . Ended up with Kamara & Golladay plus Tyreek for Dalvin essentially. Perhaps you could do something similar. But if Davis would've been available to me I wouldn't trade. McCaffrey or Cook (who I like better anyway) could be traded for a late first where I could get a Hunt / Kamara and more

User avatar
Kramer
MVP
MVP
Posts: 2839
Joined: Mon May 23, 2016 5:07 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Kramer » Sun Jul 23, 2017 2:02 pm

IBall2 wrote: Sun Jul 23, 2017 8:17 am I'm in a similar situation in my league. I own picks 1.01 1.02 and 1.04 while the league champion owns pick 1.03 and it's a 0.3 PPR league. I'm leaning towards picking Fournette/Mixon at 1 and 2. I think the owner of the 1.03 wants to pick an RB because he's stacked at WR. I'm hoping Davis falls to me at 1.04.
My league was 0.5 PPR and I had picks 1, 3, 4 and the guy at two took CMC. I was thrilled to get my top 3 players in the draft. Maybe talk to the guy and try to get an idea of what he'll be taking. Maybe his team needs RBs badly, then you can take Fournette, Mixon and let him take Cook or CMC and Davis falls to you at 4.
10 team SF .5ppr-QB,2RB,3WR,TE,Flex,SF,Def (30 spots)
QB: Allen, AR, Brissett
RB: Mixon,Barkley,Rhamondre,Foreman
WR: Deebo,Adams,Jeudy, Devonta,Nuk
TE: Knox,Chig, Woods, Ferguson
2023 picks: 2, 3, 6, 8, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 18, 19, 20
2024 picks: 3 2nds
2025 picks: 3 2nds

RightlegTucker
All Pro
All Pro
Posts: 1729
Joined: Thu Sep 18, 2014 8:37 am

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby RightlegTucker » Sun Jul 23, 2017 4:09 pm

Davis, surprised the other guy is passing on him for Cook.

User avatar
Dyno_7
Role Player
Role Player
Posts: 462
Joined: Sun Jan 15, 2017 8:49 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Dyno_7 » Sun Jul 23, 2017 6:02 pm

RightlegTucker wrote: Sun Jul 23, 2017 4:09 pm Davis, surprised the other guy is passing on him for Cook.
Me too. He told me he wanted Davis a few weeks ago. Just the other day he said he wanted Cook instead. I told him I'll happily take Davis. Lol.
TEAMS 1&2: 10tm. Non-PPR +IDP.
Starters: 1QB-2RB-3WR-1TE-1K-2DL-1EDR-3LB-3DB

TEAM 1:
QB: C.Wentz, P.Rivers, J.Rosen, L.Jackson.
RB: J.Mixon, L.Fournette, J.Howard, D.Williams
WR: O.BeckhamJr, M.Thomas, S.Diggs, J.Smith-Schuster, S.Watkins, C.Godwin, C.Sutton.
TE: Z.Ertz, M.Gesicki, G.Kittle.
DL: D.Hunter, D.Barnett, C.Jones.
EDR: H.Landry.
LB: M.Jack, Z.Cunningham, A.Williamson, L.Vander Esch, C.Littleton.
DB: R.Jones, B.McDougald, S.Williams.

TEAM 2:
QB: D.Watson.
RB: D.Cook, A.Kamara, J.Mixon, C.Hyde, N.Chubb, A.Jones.
WR: A.Cooper, M.Thomas, J.Smith-Schuster, J.Gordon, M.Williams, K.Golladay, C.Godwin, C.Kirk.
TE: E.Engram, D.Njoku, D.Goedert.
DL: K.Mack, D.Hunter, D.Ware
EDR: V.Miller
LB: T.Smith, M.Jack, D.Jones, Z.Cunningham, T.Edmunds, L.Vander Esch.
DB: B.Baker, D.James, C.Geathers.

User avatar
Dyno_7
Role Player
Role Player
Posts: 462
Joined: Sun Jan 15, 2017 8:49 pm

Re: McCaffery or Davis?

Postby Dyno_7 » Sun Jul 23, 2017 6:10 pm

Thanks for the feedback gents. I think I'll probably roll with Davis even though I'm heavy on WR's. I can always deal one of them away for a RB to balance my roster better. If I get a King's ransom for the pick I'll consider it. For now I won't overthink it.

Fournette may be the safer pick at 1.01 for a non-ppr league, but my gut is telling me to go with Mixon's versatility. He's younger, has had half the touches in college, and is a complete back. I already have two, 2 down thumpers in Ajayi & Howard. I'd like to get a guy or two that can be a true 3 down back.
TEAMS 1&2: 10tm. Non-PPR +IDP.
Starters: 1QB-2RB-3WR-1TE-1K-2DL-1EDR-3LB-3DB

TEAM 1:
QB: C.Wentz, P.Rivers, J.Rosen, L.Jackson.
RB: J.Mixon, L.Fournette, J.Howard, D.Williams
WR: O.BeckhamJr, M.Thomas, S.Diggs, J.Smith-Schuster, S.Watkins, C.Godwin, C.Sutton.
TE: Z.Ertz, M.Gesicki, G.Kittle.
DL: D.Hunter, D.Barnett, C.Jones.
EDR: H.Landry.
LB: M.Jack, Z.Cunningham, A.Williamson, L.Vander Esch, C.Littleton.
DB: R.Jones, B.McDougald, S.Williams.

TEAM 2:
QB: D.Watson.
RB: D.Cook, A.Kamara, J.Mixon, C.Hyde, N.Chubb, A.Jones.
WR: A.Cooper, M.Thomas, J.Smith-Schuster, J.Gordon, M.Williams, K.Golladay, C.Godwin, C.Kirk.
TE: E.Engram, D.Njoku, D.Goedert.
DL: K.Mack, D.Hunter, D.Ware
EDR: V.Miller
LB: T.Smith, M.Jack, D.Jones, Z.Cunningham, T.Edmunds, L.Vander Esch.
DB: B.Baker, D.James, C.Geathers.


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 17 guests