Peyton Manning vs. Tom Brady

[Dynasty DeLorean]

I used to be a Manning > Brady because he was putting up better numbers on teams that had less talent and worse coaching. However the one thing about Manning is if everything doesn't go exactly according to plan he seems to fall apart. Brady is the opposite, his level of play seems to rise when things aren't going his way.

The coaching I'll give you, but Manning's talent around him was infinitely better than Brady's.

I meant overall team talent, not who he was throwing to (I assume this is where you were going with that).

[Space Cowboy]

Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne and Edge were all great but then he had Stokley, Garcon, Rhodes, Mungro......

Off topic but I don't think Dallas Clark puts up half those #'s with 80, if not 90% of QBs.

[Opeth24]

Brady...and I don't think it's close.