Donnell Pumphrey or Jeremy Hill

[ace1250]

Should I drop Jeremy Hill for Donnell Pumphrey? Roster is in sig...

[jdomer2403]

I would hold Hill. They are praising Pumphrey but he is still behind Blount and Sproles. Might be Sproles replacement after 2017 but I am keeping Hill here.

[TeamSB]

I would keep Hill.

However, if you really want Pumphrey, I'd suggest giving up Woodhead. Yes he will contribute somewhat this year, but he's 32, returning from a torn ACL, has low trade value and I only expect him to play this year.

[Goddard]

I'd hold Hill for now.

[lukkynumber13]

This is craziness. Heck no.

I'll gladly take Hill and hope for a Legarette Blount-type resurgence in a year or 2, than hope Pumphrey someday reaches his ceiling of being Pierre Thomas.

[gopackgo]

I would keep Hill.

However, if you really want Pumphrey, I'd suggest giving up Woodhead. Yes he will contribute somewhat this year, but he's 32, returning from a torn ACL, has low trade value and I only expect him to play this year.

There's been quite a good amount of hype around Woodhead in the past few weeks. You may be able to sell him now or after the first two weeks for a '18 1st.