C. Meredith or K. White

[Space Cowboy]

Lol 65-64

Can't make this stuff up

[Away Team]

Keep in mind that White was considered extremely raw coming out of college, and basically lost the first 2 years of his career. There's no guarantee he was ever going to be the player we thought he was BEFORE the injuries.

Give me the more reliable candidate, who just so happens to look like a quality NFL receiver to boot.

[Sterling Archer]

Keep in mind that White was considered extremely raw coming out of college, and basically lost the first 2 years of his career. There's no guarantee he was ever going to be the player we thought he was BEFORE the injuries.

Give me the more reliable candidate, who just so happens to look like a quality NFL receiver to boot.

As far as athleticism goes, White's injuries are not very scary. Sure, bone injuries take a long time to heal due to blood flow, but they aren't known to physically slow anyone down like torn hamstring, achilles, or patella tendon injuries can. Unless we're talking about a gruesome compound fracture, players are typically as good as new after the bone has healed up.

So yeah, White was a raw prospect that might bust, but it won't be due to those injuries. He's still got the same odds of success today as he did 2 years ago, IMO.

[nabright]

Keep in mind that White was considered extremely raw coming out of college, and basically lost the first 2 years of his career. There's no guarantee he was ever going to be the player we thought he was BEFORE the injuries.

Give me the more reliable candidate, who just so happens to look like a quality NFL receiver to boot.

Couldn't have said it better myself. People are just assuming that IF White stays healthy, he's gonna turn into a WR1. He could very well have been a bust even if he stayed healthy in his career so far. I'm easily taking the guy who almost put up a 1000yds in his 2nd year in the league. I see no reason why he can't be a career WR2 and a go to guy for Trubisky as he develops.

[Goddard]

73-68 for CM. This might be the biggest lead either one has had. I hope this thread never dies and people continue to vote till after they're both retired.

[Sterling Archer]

This poll never left the front page. Why is there another poll exactly like it? You don't even have to search... just look on the front page. It's really not that hard..