2nd/3rd tier RBs POST-NFL Draft *Poll*

[lukkynumber13]

How would you rank these RBs for dynasty purposes? They are all in somewhat similar positions...

1. Kareem Hunt
2. Jamal Williams
3. Jeremy McNichols
4. Marlon Mack
5. Samaje Perine

[IBall2]

Perine for me, I think if he didn't have Mixon in his backfield in college we would be ranking him near the top already due to workload and production. Now people are going to get him in the middle of the second round in a good situation and he will most likely outproduce 1 or 2 of the top 4 ranked RBs in the this class.

[Cherokee]

Perine
Hunt
McNichols
Mack
Williams
Ive been pretty tough on Williams, my dude.
I really would like to see a few more names in this tier
Joe Williams
Aaron Jones. Im telling ya, Aaron Jones is nice and should give TY a run right away

[Servo]

The most important thing with these later round RBs are the ones with the immediate shot at opportunity.

Rotoviz and Kevin Cole (who I trust their RB evaluations/success models) aren't particularly high on guys like Hunt, Kamara, James Conner, Jamaal Williams, etc.

So dynasty, with the potential at a longer/more successful career?

1. McNichols
2. Joe Williams (49ers)
3. Perine
4. Mack
5. Hunt
6. Jamaal Williams (GB)

Immediate shot at producing on your team and probably being overdrafted?

1. Perine
2. Hunt/Mack
3. Joe Williams
4. McNichols

[CK_]

Love me some Hunt and Joe Williams. Don't believe in Carlos Hyde at all.

[jryanw]

Perine and hunt have the best chance of seeing the field early and often. The rest will prob be dropped and picked up a couple of times this year in mid to small leagues.(edit) I don't love mcnichols talent but he's in a really good situation in TB.

[Ryantacular]

Perine
Hunt
Joe Williams (Not Jamal)

Everyone else

[lukkynumber13]

Perine
Hunt
Joe Williams (Not Jamal)

Everyone else

I just traded Perine, Hunt, & Julio for Moncrief. Good trade?

[Zak_Dewitt]

It's Perine, Hunt, then Jamal Williams for me. Perine can easily beat out Fat Rob for the starting job there. In Hunt's case, I don't think he opens as the starter but he has a very similar skill set to Ware but better IMO. I also really like Jamal Williams and think he is underrated but I don't think Monty gets taken out of the picture immediately but Williams will be starting a year or two.

[Goddard]

Perine is easily first on this list. I'm debating between Mack and Hunt for #2.

[Ryantacular]

Perine
Hunt
Joe Williams (Not Jamal)

Everyone else

I just traded Perine, Hunt, & Julio for Moncrief. Good trade?

The Julio side should have had to add at least 2 high firsts. What a steal for Moncrief.

[iceman68]

Everyone else
[/quote]
I just traded Perine, Hunt, & Julio for Moncrief. Good trade?
[/quote]

That's a horrible trade if you are getting Moncrief. If you traded Moncrief away, then that's spectacular.

[Ryantacular]

Everyone else
I just traded Perine, Hunt, & Julio for Moncrief. Good trade?

That's a horrible trade if you are getting Moncrief. If you traded Moncrief away, then that's spectacular.

He's not being serious at all. Me and him have this lovers quarrel thing.

[IDPAuthority]

1) Hunt
2) McNichols
3) Perine
4) Williams
5) Mack

Talent before situation. Although situation does still factor into the equation.

[spotxc]

no kamara in here at all