Tyrell Williams vs Keenan Allen

[crisdecamposmd]

How do you see these guys playing out over the next 1 year? Next 4 years?

[Goddard]

How do you see these guys playing out over the next 1 year? Next 4 years?

Assuming Allen stays healthy, there's absolutely no reason to think Tyrell will be better (unless you listen to Skip).

[roseyknee]

With all of these posts, I've been answering with relative costs in mind. In this case, I like both Allen and Williams. I think they will both be productive in that offense and wouldn't have a problem investing in both of them at their current values.

[onetwothree]

Different types of WR that win in different areas of the field in different ways. I think they can co-exist and compliment each other very well but it's all contingent on Rivers remaining a viable passer. Keenan should be the volume guy with his route running while Tyrell is the deep threat, big play guy with his size and speed.

Will be wanting to see if Tyrell makes a big jump this year without the pressure of being WR1 and also learning a few tricks from Keenan.

[keebs3]

I also like both. I own Tyrell and think he will have another good year, regardless of Allen's health. If Allen can stay healthy he likely has the better overall value over the next few years.

[lic217]

I would take Allen over Trell. I think KA has top 5 wr in PPR this year if he stays healthy. Although I have said that quite a few times. Tyrell is a nice WR but the ceiling is not as high, but injury risk is lower.

[Mike from Canada]

Allen for sure.

[onetwothree]

I would take Allen over Trell. I think KA has top 5 wr in PPR this year if he stays healthy. Although I have said that quite a few times. Tyrell is a nice WR but the ceiling is not as high, but injury risk is lower.

Disagree on ceiling. Tyrell had Julio measurements. Just raw coming out. Still getting better. Not saying he'll get there but the physical gifts means the ceiling is the roof.

[Kramer]

I would take Allen over Trell. I think KA has top 5 wr in PPR this year if he stays healthy. Although I have said that quite a few times. Tyrell is a nice WR but the ceiling is not as high, but injury risk is lower.

Disagree on ceiling. Tyrell had Julio measurements. Just raw coming out. Still getting better. Not saying he'll get there but the physical gifts means the ceiling is the roof.

Agreed. Tyrell has as high a ceiling as anyone in the league. Most people including me will take Allen ahead of Tyrell at the moment. However, for their respective price, give me Tyrell all day.

[ManhattanProject]

What would you say is the price of Tyrell now? I was thinking of offering 2.05? Too much? I'm trying a ppr rebuild and have literally zero talent but 4 1st rounder and 2.02 thru 2.05.

[onetwothree]

What would you say is the price of Tyrell now? I was thinking of offering 2.05? Too much? I'm trying a ppr rebuild and have literally zero talent but 4 1st rounder and 2.02 thru 2.05.

Makes sense to deal 1 of your 8 picks but based on some of the posts today, you're about to get him for free when he fades into Bolivian...

[lic217]

I would take Allen over Trell. I think KA has top 5 wr in PPR this year if he stays healthy. Although I have said that quite a few times. Tyrell is a nice WR but the ceiling is not as high, but injury risk is lower.

Disagree on ceiling. Tyrell had Julio measurements. Just raw coming out. Still getting better. Not saying he'll get there but the physical gifts means the ceiling is the roof.

Not Julio measurements. 20 lbs lighter. What makes Julio special is how he carries that big frame. 20 lbs is a lot. Tyrell did not bench because of his shoulder injury. I would like to know what it was coming out of college. I also think we need to not get to excited about measurements. I remember Julio's rookie year when he took two slants in one game to the house. He made the CB's and safeties look like they were standing still. I think Julio runs a 4.3 with his pads on. Guy is a freak.
Tyrell Williams has some incredible athletic gifts and agree with you saying his ceiling is extremely high. I do not think his ceiling is as high for next year. For the long term, he has as much potential as almost anyone.