Moncrief x Parker x Coleman

[kaius]

Question marks and asterisks next to each of these guys, but sky's the limit depending on what evidence you choose to take as gospel. Considering all of their physical talents, team situations, and immediate and long term outlook; how would you rank them?

[Servo]

You'd feel that at this point, Coleman has the clear cut opportunity to become his team's true WR1....I guess it would be contingent upon whether or not you believe he is capable.

Moncrief is entering Year 4 and will be 24 at the start of this season....everyone has been waiting....will Kamar Aiken take his spot? Will Dorsett step up to his 1st Round pedigree? A story like Davante Adams may tell you to not write off someone just yet but how many times will we expect Moncrief to actually progress?

[kaius]

Yeah, Moncrief is the one who puzzles me most. Limited playing time and touchdown dependent fantasy production (as if TDs are a bad thing). He's yet to finish out top-30 yet many have no issue ranking him top 20 overall Dynasty asset. He has the best QB situation, but he's clearly second fiddle to Hilton and has Dorset and now Aiken on his heels. Can he stay healthy and keep up the TD rate?

I feel like Coleman has a clear path to WR1 status (no one to really compete with for targets and could take the Pryor move as a vote of confidence), but he doesn't have a QB and that's a little bit important for most WRs. Will being a Brown hold him back or will Hue Jackson make the Percy Harvin comparisons more than just hype?

Parker has all of the physical tools and ball-hawk, bully-ball, big-play ability, but has to compete with Landry (who is a much more polished WR) and has had his work ethic called out by his head coach. Human highlight reel with your typical "alpha wideout" personality traits. He showed his potential at the end of his rookie year and then his 2016 took the air out of our sails. Can he back up his hype?

[Ryantacular]

Coleman and Parker have a shot. Parker has his well known work ethics delimas, nutrition/workout problems, etc. But we have all seen the talent. Same with Coleman when it comes to talent, we have all seen it, just the team needs to get things together. These two players can actually succeed if things fall in line.

Moncrief, however, just no way. Just watch his film. No talent. Baby hands. Cant catch a damn thing. He flat out sucks. People arguing for him, see his stats and situation, but dont actually watch his film and its apparent.

[Goddard]

It's between Coleman and Parker for me. If Cleveland gets a decent QB, I'll take Coleman.

[lukkynumber13]

Moncrief, however, just no way. Just watch his film. No talent. Baby hands. Cant catch a damn thing. He flat out sucks. People arguing for him, see his stats and situation, but dont actually watch his film and its apparent.

People, just FYI, I have Ryantacular's personal home address on file, in case anyone wants to egg it or TP it. Message me!

[lukkynumber13]

1. Parker I would pay the 1.06 for EASILY
2. Coleman I would pay the 1.06 or 1.07 for but I think he has a SLIGHTLY lower career ceiling

3. Moncrief I would pay a late First, say 1.11 or 12. He has as high of a floor as the others, but not the ceiling IMO.

[skip]

Coleman is the most talented of the group and the only one of the 3 I would want on my team. His value seems pretty depressed right now as somehow people seem to think he's worth a lower pick in this year's class than last year's which is just absurd.

Parker and Moncrief both seem to be valued higher than either will ever produce. Both are behind clearly better options in their respective offenses and both have failed to produce well enough or consistently enough to ever yield the right return on value. I'd be selling either of them at current market prices.

[Ryantacular]

Moncrief, however, just no way. Just watch his film. No talent. Baby hands. Cant catch a damn thing. He flat out sucks. People arguing for him, see his stats and situation, but dont actually watch his film and its apparent.

People, just FYI, I have Ryantacular's personal home address on file, in case anyone wants to egg it or TP it. Message me!

Lukky is my psycho ex, who I'm still in love with. Please dont get my address from him, he's already posted on CL.

[lic217]

I think I am going to choose Coleman of the three, but I might have a different answer tomorrow morning.

[senska11]

Coleman, Moncrief, Parker. Coleman way ahead of the other two who are both close.