Debate of Knuckleheads

[Never Veto1]

Which would you prefer if given the choice, you have to pick one, and why him? Sorry if this has been listed previously

Josh Gordon
or
Martavis Bryant

[skip]

First choice is neither. Second choice is Bryant because someone in your league may be foolish enough to pay a first round pick for him after reinstatement.

[Cowboysfan33]

I'd take Bryant. He's a little younger, less suspensions(I think) so it seems like there's more upside in him. Gordon hasn't played in like 2 years, who knows what he could do now, even if he gets another chance.

[onetwothree]

Martavis is not as far removed and has a better QB situation. Actually added both for cheap as it was the easiest path to a potential WR1. End of roster holds.

[Favrezilla]

i was lucky enough to draft them both in my '14 startup dynasty for team 2 (along with AP, Foles, RG3 and Keenan - efffmylife)

i think Martavis is the safer bet and in a good system for him, even if both come back and arent getting in trouble i think Gordon has a harder draw every week.

[23B_Mills]

i was lucky enough to draft them both in my '14 startup dynasty for team 2 (along with AP, Foles, RG3 and Keenan - efffmylife)

i think Martavis is the safer bet and in a good system for him, even if both come back and arent getting in trouble i think Gordon has a harder draw every week.

Ouch.

I'd rather have Bryant, but I wouldn't pay much for him.

[esloan35]

This is too funny. I just stay away from knuckleheads. If I had to pick one I guess it would be Gordon if he gets to come back. Ughhhh..

[Goddard]

I'd take Bryant. He's a little younger, less suspensions(I think) so it seems like there's more upside in him. Gordon hasn't played in like 2 years, who knows what he could do now, even if he gets another chance.

This would be my answer. Gordon is the superior talent in my opinion, but I have a feeling he never plays another down in the NFL...which is sad because I was a huge fan.

[lukkynumber13]

First choice is neither. Second choice is Bryant because someone in your league may be foolish enough to pay a first round pick for him after reinstatement.

X2

Josh Gordon is almost to Blackmon's level of complete irrelevancy. You might argue he's already there actually.

Martavis Bryant can still get back and be good, probably. I'm not gonna bank on it, but I wouldn't be shocked if you told me he got back in the league and put up WR2 seasons for 2-3 years. Whereas, if you told me Gordon ever puts up WR2 numbers again, I would be absolutely shocked.

[Steelersfan]

Bryant.