Harvin-Cruz trade

[TryingToWin]

PPR league that gives bonuses for long plays.

Give Percy Harvin and 2.02
Get Victor Cruz and 1.03

[joeday]

meh. lol

I wouldnt find inclined either way.

[BPP]

Love both of them; would take the pick.

[TryingToWin]

Others care to weigh in?

[FarNorthAK]

Id rather have Harvin.

[Seventy5]

I prefer Harvin over Cruz by quite a bit, so if I'm going for established players I'd take Harvin and worry about rookies later once the sheen wears off

[kellysheroes]

PPR league that gives bonuses for long plays.

Give Percy Harvin and 2.02
Get Victor Cruz and 1.03

I think it's obvious I should do this but I'm such a Harvin believer for top 5 talent.

I'd take that, and wouldn't give Cruz 1.03 for Harvin; misses too many games

[sugbear65]

I'd actually prefer the Percy side. He is in the top 5 WRs for me in PPR. Cruz is no slouch himself, and the 1.03 is a good pick. But I think Percy, more so now with Wilson throwing him the ball, is more of a differance maker than Cruz. And 2.02 should still fetch a nice prospect in this deep class. I'd stick, or if you wanted to move up find an alternative method not using Harvin

[Orangedawg]

I like Harvin better, but think that Cruz is close enough, to do it, to get the 1.03.

[Jfever]

Cruz side. Harvin's move to Seatle will drop his fantasy production. Write that down. in ppr Cruz is just as good if not better than Harvin, Cruz is just as good if not better in the long TD department. Cruz is more durable... and Cruz is less of a diva. Cruz also doesn't get migranes and miss 80% of his practices. Wilson looked good but he isn't nearly as dependable as Manning is.

1.03 >>>> to the 2.02

I'm shocked people side with Harvin on this one. He is no longer going to be force fed the ball like he was with the Vikings. So... no longer is he a top 5 dynasty asset.

Just my 2 cents.

[doktor]

... and Cruz is less of a diva.

Touche.

( But I'm telling you, I'll revive these threads this time next year. :duel: )

[jrnall2]

Wow. Lots of responses for Cruz here. Seems pretty even.

[Jfever]

Can't wait to re visit this thread. I'm telling you when Harvin isn't utilized like Harvin wants to up in the Pacific north west... He'll become a diva like Pete Carroll has never seen. Write that down too.

Cruz will get his contract from NYG. For gods sake he set a Franchise ALL TIME record... and they are an old franchise. The kid deserves much more credit than he receives in fantasy circles as well as real life football. the cream always rises to the top. Cruz = Cream...

[dlf_jacobf]

I think their production this year will be closer than people expect, so while Harvin probably has more upside, I think the players are pretty even given situation, injury history, etc. That means I'm going to take the side with the better pick. Give me Cruz and the 1.03

[BuckeyeNation]

Cruz side. Harvin's move to Seatle will drop his fantasy production. Write that down. in ppr Cruz is just as good if not better than Harvin, Cruz is just as good if not better in the long TD department. Cruz is more durable... and Cruz is less of a diva. Cruz also doesn't get migranes and miss 80% of his practices. Wilson looked good but he isn't nearly as dependable as Manning is.

1.03 >>>> to the 2.02

I'm shocked people side with Harvin on this one. He is no longer going to be force fed the ball like he was with the Vikings. So... no longer is he a top 5 dynasty asset.

Just my 2 cents.

I thought I was the only one that felt this way. Might as well get on record now before it happens.