Another owner really hunting my kamara

[zarathustra]

Getting offered dalvin, Corey Davis, 1.05 and 2020 1st for Kamara and cooks.

How far off is this? Kamara is tough to value.

[LMS123]

That’s fair; I’d say;
Cook = Cooks
Kamara = Davis, and the 1sts

[zarathustra]

That’s fair; I’d say;
Cook = Cooks
Kamara = Davis, and the 1sts

Do you think it improves my team? Assuming a 1st hits

[The Red Rooster]

Theres no way I would give Kamara AND Cooks for all of those question marks. In fairness tho, those question marks do have high ceilings but this is an easy pass for me.

[LMS123]

That’s fair; I’d say;
Cook = Cooks
Kamara = Davis, and the 1sts

Do you think it improves my team? Assuming a 1st hits

Assuming they hit I’d say it improves your depth no doubt; but it depends how you define ‘hit’. Top 20 at their position it’s surely does but if they become 150-200 point guys I’d rather have Kamara and Cooks

[mariettajeff]

No friggin way would I take what's offered for Kamara. And I own both Cooks and Davis.

[zarathustra]

Ok, help me structure a deal.
This is owner's team:

https://sleeper.app/roster/387336453673504768/4

[Zacsby]

I'd pass on that deal. Would probably think about it more if it was Cook/Davis/2020 1st for Kamara

[M-Dub]

I'd pass on that deal. Would probably think about it more if it was Cook/Davis/2020 1st for Kamara

That’s what I was thinking. Keep Cooks and take out Davis or one of the 1sts on his end.

[Gator Sens]

Easy pass

[Panthers357]

I'd keep Kamara

[repkllrs]

Kamara isn’t tough to value. He is a top 6 start up pick. I think you need Kamara more than the pieces coming back. If you are determined to trade him away, I would want DJ Moore instead of CDavis.

[Finfansteve]

Stay put this trade will hurt your team

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Cooks >= Cook
Kamara >> Davis + 1.05 + 2020 1st

Pretty terrible offer as is. I'd counter with Kamara + 2nd for Cook + 1.05 + 2020 1st.

[Kmani6]

AWFUL AWFUL AWFUL. You're not giving up even Kamara + 2020 2nd for Cook and the 2 1st's. It's gotta be Kamara alone for Cook plus the 2 firsts to begin considering the offer. Like another user mentioned, worst case switch Davis with DJ Moore. I mean what is the 1.05 in this draft, a random WR that you're hoping to hit on? I'm really high on Cook, and I have him in a league. If he gets injured again this year it's over. Literally his fantasy value is zero. The risk for a Zeke like fantasy value is not worth it at all. Kamarra has proven for 2 straight years now that he's amazing. On top of that he's on an elite offense, and is being managed extremely well. I'll take the 1600 and 18 TD seasons for years to come, rather than him being a total workhorse and topping 2k like twice. Kamara easily has that talent though, and it was extremely evident in the first four games of last season with how he managed the whole workload. Either way Kamara is going to be a stud RB for years to come, there's no point taking a risk on Dalvin Cook.