Antonio Brown versus Kelce

[jordanzs]

12 team PPR.

Who you got in a trade here? I could give Antonio Brown for Kelce.

I do have Evan Engram & Herndon already, but I could trade Engram for a WR of similar value I think.

I have a win-now team. my top WRs are Hopkins, Brown, Tyreek, Golladay. Also got Fuller, Kirk, Watkins, Daesean.

I was really thinking about doing this before Tyreek got Tyreek's and Engram had the ODB shackles removed. Now I'm just sorta lukewarm or thinking to hold & hope for the best on AB.

If I play 3 RBs, then I only need to start 3 WRs. or I can do a 2rb/4wr lineup. My RBs are Dalvin, Fournette, Ingram, Latavius, Hynes, Dion Lewis. So in otherwords my RBs are vulnerable to injuries & question marks, but they could also be solid.

[FantasyFreak]

Brown for me. I think he's got more juice left than Kelce. Kelce with his surgery worries me slightly, but I just think AB can be productive at a high level for some years, still.

[jetsfan5757]

I'm on the AB side too. Engram and Herndon are solid. I wouldn't give up a few years of top 10 WR production for an upgrade at TE...

[Cowboysfan33]

I’m also on the AB side. I would keep what you have. You can do the 2/4 lineup, like you mentioned and you will have a really good lineup that should be hard to beat, with Cook/Fournette or Ingram/ Hopkins/AB/Tyreek/Golladay/Engram, assuming Hill isn’t suspended. I’m expecting a bounce back from Engram this season too, so I would just keep your team as is, for now.

[PR0v3]

Kelce for sure. ABs best days are behind him and he’s in a mediocre situation. Also, vet WRs changing teams do not have a strong track record of maintaining their production.

Kelce right now is pretty much as valuable as a TE is ever going to be. I think he’s worth more than AB so even if I needed the WR I’d look to flip him.

[FuzzySignificance]

I'd rather have Kelce myself. Position scarcity, impending karmic retribution for being mean to Juju, etc. but mostly because there are a lot more people in my leagues willing to pay up for Kelce than Brown.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Depends on how many WRs you start in that league. If just 2 plus a flex, I'd take Kelce. If it's 3+ WRs, it would make it much closer.

[Goddard]

I'd rather have Kelce between the two, but losing AB hurts your WR depth. Tough call.

[Gator Sens]

Kelce for me. He should still have a few years of elite production

[jordanzs]

Depends on how many WRs you start in that league. If just 2 plus a flex, I'd take Kelce. If it's 3+ WRs, it would make it much closer.

We start a minimum of 3 WRs. Can flex a 4th

[PercyR1]

AB