Lindsay or Pettis + '19 1.12

[Raptus]

which side do you like?

thanks in advance

[lukkynumber13]

I think Lindsay and Pettis are about equal (specific team build factors hugely) in a dynasty setting, slight edge to Lindsay perhaps.

I have faith in me being able to draft a solid prospect at 12 tho. Give me Pettis and the pick.

[Goddard]

I wouldn't pay that for Lindsay, but probably would want more if I'm selling. I guess that means it's probably fair value.

[AresGodOWar]

For me
Lindsay = pick 2-3
Pettis = pick 10-12

Add the 1.12 and I don't think I would take 2 late 1st for a top 3 pick

[LMS123]

For me
Lindsay = pick 2-3
Pettis = pick 10-12

Add the 1.12 and I don't think I would take 2 late 1st for a top 3 pick

You think Lindsay has the same value as the 1.02-1.03? Im not saying that in an attacking sense I’m just interested in your stance on that; I’d place him more 1.06 range but wouldn’t trade the 1.06 for him personally

[AresGodOWar]

For me
Lindsay = pick 2-3
Pettis = pick 10-12

Add the 1.12 and I don't think I would take 2 late 1st for a top 3 pick

You think Lindsay has the same value as the 1.02-1.03? Im not saying that in an attacking sense I’m just interested in your stance on that; I’d place him more 1.06 range but wouldn’t trade the 1.06 for him personally

Yeah I do top 13 RB as a rookie without a QB , I paid the 1.05 , 3.05 and was very happy to do it.

He just went 2 spots after the 1.02 and 27 spots before the 1.03 in my SF startup to someone else , So I guess others think he is worth more than the 1.03.

[jcc6fd]

Trade is close to fair if you're realistic about Pettis but I'd prefer Lindsay. He's a fantasy relevant starter. Pettis probably won't be.

[Gator Sens]

Lindsay side as of now