AB vs Keenan Allen

[mike40]

Simple question. Who do you prefer over the next 3 years.
AB or KA

[Gator Sens]

Allen. Age and situation

[The Showstopper]

In going AB here...I’ll give you age with Kennan, but I’m not sure his situation is better...I’m not sure Mike Williams isn’t the better WR in 2 years...Him and Henry taking red zone targets and the dump offs to Gordon an Eckler..Rivers is better than Carr, but AB May get 200 targets on that team...Plus even at 30 he’s MUCH more talented then Allen...Still close only because of age..But if your talking 3 years..Give me Mr. Big Chest!

[BeeziBad]

It's close. I hear the Allen and his age argument but as Williams and Henry heat up, who will be Rivers' replacement's fav target when the time comes? When will that time come? Will Gruden and Carr turn it around? How will Brown react under a new QB? When will father time kick in? These guys bring a lot of questions. Both guys have been studs and consistent, but I really don't know what life will be like in Oakland. I'm pretty sure Brown still more expensive than Allen, but I like Allen better, slightly.

[AlPal&Ange]

Next 3 years AB, any longer than that KA

[murphysxm]

Allen has missed 26 games in 6 seasons, Brown 14 in 9, kind of negates the age thing for me. Plus Brown has much less target competition

[mike40]

Still debating on who I should trade for. I can get either of them for the same price. Leaning towards AB right now. Anybody else have an opinion?

[Hottoddies]

I don't think Rivers will lose his love of targeting Allen. AB is older and can be a bit of a head case.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Allen due to age, but I wouldn't add more than a 2nd to Brown to get him.