Pick a side; big trade

[Phaded]

PPR.

[Gator Sens]

Barkley side but man, they are both great!

[TrojanDynasty32]

I’d have to say the Barkley side, as Barkley, Kelce & 1.07 are noticeably better than Gordon, OJ & 1.10. Thomas is better than JuJu, but the numbers will be close, so the only real advantage here is Godwin v. Evans, which is by far the biggest gap between the players, but wouldn’t be enough for me to consider trading Barkley.

[zarathustra]

let's dissect this. now assign values for how much the delta is. personally, I think the delta between Thomas and Evans over juju and Godwin is more than compensating for the delta between gordon and Barkley.

that's just me, and it's late. and I might be drunk.

picks are neutral.
Kelce > Howard
Juju < Thomas
Godwin < Evans
Barkley > Gordon

[LMS123]

Barkley is much better than Gordon; juju is to close Thomas, Godwin is close to OJ and Evans, 1.07 is better than 1.10

The difference between Barkley and Gordon makes up for the difference between juju and Godwin so for me this is the Barkley side

[honcho55]

Had a thing typed out. Lost it.

Bottom line, at first glance it looked pretty fair, digging in I like the Barkley side

[EAGLES]

I went with the Barkley side for 2 reasons. 1) Gordon’s knee/injuries have been occurring every season and 2) having Kelce is a big advantage at the TE slot over Howard

[smallxl]

I’d have to say the Barkley side, as Barkley, Kelce & 1.07 are noticeably better than Gordon, OJ & 1.10. Thomas is better than JuJu, but the numbers will be close, so the only real advantage here is Godwin v. Evans, which is by far the biggest gap between the players, but wouldn’t be enough for me to consider trading Barkley.

Melvin Gordon is elite. So I am not of the opinion that Barkley is that much better. But don't like getting Evans and Howard.

[mmass]

Fair to even trade... though personally I want Barkley every where I can get him.

[Cowboysfan33]

Barkley side for me. I like the youth and upside on that side better than the other side, but that side definitely has some great players.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Barkley >= Thomas
JuJu >= Gordon
Kelce = Evans
Godwin = Howard
1.07 >= 1.10

This is very even, but I'd lean the Barkley side by a little bit.