Dalvin or 1.1

[PercyR1]

.5 ppr 12 team

QB
3-WR
2-RB
TE
Flex(TE/WR/RB)

[Gator Sens]

Cook by a lot for me

[Titans95]

Dalvin and not all that close for me

[PercyR1]

This is what i figured, just wanted to double check.

[RB6]

Cook with ease.

[FantasyFreak]

I don't know about all this with ease, and not close thing. To each their own, but it's quite possible a guy like Jacobs has a better career. I do have Dalvin, but he hasn't shown the ability to play a full season yet, and although he's talented, his talent isn't so far superior that I think it isn't close. I'd like to see Jacobs at the combine and draft before I say how close it is. Might even be the 1.01 for me by the time the process is finished.

[RAB]

If you drafted Dalvin 1.04 two years ago and you watched him put up RB66 and RB31 seasons in 2 years of .5 point ppr, you might feel like getting a 1.01 now could be your last opportunity to get your money back.

[RB6]

If you drafted Dalvin 1.04 two years ago and you watched him put up RB66 and RB31 seasons in 2 years of .5 point ppr, you might feel like getting a 1.01 now could be your last opportunity to get your money back.

This is incredibly misleading. He tore his ACL 4 games into his rookie season. He then missed 5 games in his sophmore campaign. Pre-ACL he looked great.

[FantasyFreak]

If you drafted Dalvin 1.04 two years ago and you watched him put up RB66 and RB31 seasons in 2 years of .5 point ppr, you might feel like getting a 1.01 now could be your last opportunity to get your money back.

This is incredibly misleading. He tore his ACL 4 games into his rookie season. He then missed 5 games in his sophmore campaign. Pre-ACL he looked great.

He should be better another year removed from it, too. However I don't know why people think he's worth significantly more than the 1.01, and I have him in some places.

[FantasyFreak]

If you drafted Dalvin 1.04 two years ago and you watched him put up RB66 and RB31 seasons in 2 years of .5 point ppr, you might feel like getting a 1.01 now could be your last opportunity to get your money back.

This is incredibly misleading. He tore his ACL 4 games into his rookie season. He then missed 5 games in his sophmore campaign. Pre-ACL he looked great.

He should be better another year removed from it, too. However I don't know why people think he's worth significantly more than the 1.01, and I have him in some places. That said, I drafted him over 1.01 in a recent startup, but I still think it's a toss up.

[Vcize]

If you drafted Dalvin 1.04 two years ago and you watched him put up RB66 and RB31 seasons in 2 years of .5 point ppr, you might feel like getting a 1.01 now could be your last opportunity to get your money back.

This is incredibly misleading. He tore his ACL 4 games into his rookie season. He then missed 5 games in his sophmore campaign. Pre-ACL he looked great.

Back to back injury riddled seasons for a guy that had injury concerns coming into the league isn't exactly a good thing.

It is looking more and more like Jacobs is going to have higher NFL draft capital than Cook. Situation is of course still unknown but there are some very good ones out there.

Cook wasn't able to plant Latavius Murray on the bench this year.

[Titans95]

If you drafted Dalvin 1.04 two years ago and you watched him put up RB66 and RB31 seasons in 2 years of .5 point ppr, you might feel like getting a 1.01 now could be your last opportunity to get your money back.

This is incredibly misleading. He tore his ACL 4 games into his rookie season. He then missed 5 games in his sophmore campaign. Pre-ACL he looked great.

He should be better another year removed from it, too. However I don't know why people think he's worth significantly more than the 1.01, and I have him in some places. That said, I drafted him over 1.01 in a recent startup, but I still think it's a toss up.

I like Jacobs a lot but it could turn out that both him and Montgomery don't end up on a dream team like the chiefs or Philly. Not mention that yes Jacobs is a pretty decent prospect but he wouldn't have been anywhere near the top RB's from the 2017 class and probably towards the backend of the RB's from last years class if he was coming into the league then. Not saying he's not good prospect because I have him as the RB1 in this class as well but he's had 120 carries that equated to just 5.3 ypc last year on the best O-line you could ask for. There has been more bust alabama RB's than hit's in recent memory so unless he goes to the chiefs its not even close for me. Cook was an absolute stud workhorse in college and was an elite prospect, his career has been unfortunate so far but I don't think it's due to ability and yes the hamstring injury is a slight concern but one soft tissue injury and a freak ACL in 6 years isn't something to hit the panic button on yet.

[Titans95]

If you drafted Dalvin 1.04 two years ago and you watched him put up RB66 and RB31 seasons in 2 years of .5 point ppr, you might feel like getting a 1.01 now could be your last opportunity to get your money back.

This is incredibly misleading. He tore his ACL 4 games into his rookie season. He then missed 5 games in his sophmore campaign. Pre-ACL he looked great.

Back to back injury riddled seasons for a guy that had injury concerns coming into the league isn't exactly a good thing.

It is looking more and more like Jacobs is going to have higher NFL draft capital than Cook. Situation is of course still unknown but there are some very good ones out there.

Cook wasn't able to plant Latavius Murray on the bench this year.

What injury concerns? He didn't miss a single game in college. Again I like Jacobs as the RB1 in this class but he isn't even close to the same prospect as Cook coming into the league.

[Bot101]

1.01 for me.

[Pantherbro13]

I’ll take 1.1 here.

Cook has two 100 yard rushing games in two seasons and has been plagued by leg injuries since entering the league. I just moved him in a deal to get Mixon because I don’t think Cook will ever be a guy to carry the load for 16 games. You might be able to get more than 1.1 for Cook since so many people seem to be high on him but I wouldn’t decline 1.1 for him if it’s your best offer.