Kirk or M Williams

[CooperCrush]

What is the difference between Mike Williams and Christian Kirk and who do you value more. Was offered Williams and 2.10 for Kirk and 3.2. I am honestly not sure of who has more value going forward??

[jpusmc0311]

I'm a huge fan of Kirk, but I think Williams is slightly ahead of him.

[jwb32]

I know many were down on Williams coming out and felt he was overdrafted, and I'm no film expert, but I really liked what I saw of Williams. I think I'd go Williams, but I don't think there is a wrong answer here.

[snaps06]

I'm invested in both in various leagues. I was very high on both, and consider them basically even. Williams probably has more TD upside, and Kirk has more yardage and receptions upside IMO.

Right now Williams is a tiny bit ahead because he's had more flashes and is tied to a solid QB.

[Goddard]

Williams is probably worth more right now, but not by a lot. I think Kirk has a shot at being the team's #1 guy though, so I probably would prefer him straight up. Williams won't be as consistent and will have plenty of competition.

[Johnny Canuck]

Williams is probably worth more right now, but not by a lot. I think Kirk has a shot at being the team's #1 guy though, so I probably would prefer him straight up. Williams won't be as consistent and will have plenty of competition.

pretty much this^

Think they are about equivalent at the moment.

I think Williams has a safer floor due, but Kirk has a higher ceiling.

Just depends what you want, do you want that safe mid WR2 with Williams, or do you want to take the risk that Kirk will be a productive number 1WR in the Arizona offense.

I'll give a slight edge to Kirk due to being two yrs younger, and with an emerging QB instead of an aging one. That said it's prob a 51/49 split.

Also in any ppr league I would prefer Kirk, while I would want Williams in standard.

[snuffalupicus]

I like Williams by a lot. He did well in what was technically his rookie year since he spent most of his rookie season injured. The only draw back is how much longer will Rivers be elite?

[BigBawseRoss]

kinda bizarre trade, ignore the picks and see who you like more, no way i would let a 4 slot move impact any decision.

think williams is set as a red zone/big play type weapon, think kirk will see more 7+ catch games. no faith in rosen at all though, he was flat out bad.

if going for a title in 2019 i pick williams, if needing a wr2 for future and looking more towards 2020 and beyond i prob go with kirk

[Gator Sens]

Mike Williams for me. I think he is going to come into his own next year. I also think kirk will turn into a very nice WR too, but I feel Williams could be dominate in the future.

[The.Big.Spank]

My fade is toward Williams, but like the guy said, no bad choice here.

[Nick110]

For me it’s williams by a significant amount. Essentially sharing a role with Tyrell Williams he was still very productive. I wouldn’t expect tyrell back and for mike to take over a fair portion of his targets. Kirk is a talented player but I can’t see Rosen taking a significant step forward with how bad that roster is.

[diamonddave]

What is the difference between Mike Williams and Christian Kirk and who do you value more. Was offered Williams and 2.10 for Kirk and 3.2. I am honestly not sure of who has more value going forward??

i like mike here.