Cook+ or Kittle+

[Dynasty19]

What side would you prefer in full PPR? This is assuming you don’t need to start dalvin and that your only tight ends are jimmy graham and Jordan reed.

Dalvin Cook, 1.7 and Jimmy Graham

Kittle, 1.4 and Chris Godwin

[Jigga94]

If you don't need Cook, I think it's a good deal

[Titans95]

I'd rather have Cook than Kittle. Love them both but despite the TE positional scarcity I still think a top 7-10 RB is worth more than a top 3 TE.

[Jigga94]

I'd rather have Cook than Kittle. Love them both but despite the TE positional scarcity I still think a top 7-10 RB is worth more than a top 3 TE.

By that thinking, you're right. I guess I didn't see Cook as a top 10 RB

[Pullo Vision]

Need to see roster, league size and starting requirements to give useful feedback. Without that, I'd prefer Cook.

[Dynasty19]

Need to see roster, league size and starting requirements to give useful feedback. Without that, I'd prefer Cook.

Start two RB and one TE

I have Gurley, Zeke, Barkley and cook but only have jimmy graham and Jordan reed at TE

[PTW32]

Kittle

[Titans95]

I'd rather have Cook than Kittle. Love them both but despite the TE positional scarcity I still think a top 7-10 RB is worth more than a top 3 TE.

By that thinking, you're right. I guess I didn't see Cook as a top 10 RB

I'm higher on him than most. I liked him more than LF as a complete back coming into the league and I loved what I saw his rookie campaign. I'm not downgrading him because of a lost season due to injury. If you watched any of the games he played in its pretty clear he is as dynamic as ever.

[M-Dub]

I see Cook and Kittle as pretty much even. Would come down to team need. I think the additional pieces push the value towards the Kittle side. Godwin > Graham and 1.04 is obviously better than 1.07. Considering you’re unlikely to start Cook, this seems like a smart move to make.

[FantasyFoosball]

Yup, based on your team, this is pretty easily the Kittle side for me.

[Z$$$]

Kittle based on team need and requirements

[Ravenous]

Considering this is off-season....i wouldn't weight team needs very high.
If your league is active....perhaps hold cook and trade him closer to the start of the season? It would really suck if you traded Cook for Kittle and he tore his acl before the season starts.

[Jigga94]

It would really suck if you traded Player A for Player B and he tore his acl before the season starts.

I agree with the sentiment that it's off season and team needs don't need to be addressed this early but do you see why that's a dangerous game of "what if" to play?

[honcho55]

Wow, I love Kittle but I’d sell him for Cook immediately. The difference in the other pieces doesn’t change that.

That said, with your other 3 RBs I don’t see why out wouldn’t sell one for a te and this isn’t a bad deal.

[jaykay22]

Kittle side by far for me.