Offer for Rodgers (SF)

[Bay City Original]

This past season saw me underachieving and going into a rebuild mode to avoid being a perennial mediocre team. This trade came to me today:

I Give: ARodgers, Ingram, DJax
I Get: Stafford, Michel, Keenum, Crowell, 2019 2nd (#3-5) and 2020 1st

Notables on my SuperFlex squad:
QB: Rodgers, Luck, Mayfield
RB: Ingram, Duke, Penny
WR: Cooper, CDavis, Fuller
TE: Howard
2019: 1st (3), 2nd (3)
2020: 1st (2), 2nd (1)

I’m looking for opinions about the value of this trade... thanks!

[Jigga94]

Take Ingram and Keenum out and I'm good with it. Keenum holds value due to SF but does little for your team. I wouldnt be buying him as part of this

[keebs3]

Seems like good value. But I'd be hesitant to include Ingram. I'd try to take him out along with maybe Crowell and the 2nd? And Keenum?
I think the core of Rodgers for Stafford/Sony/2020 1st seems pretty good.

[Goddard]

I like the trade.

[moishetreats]

This past season saw me underachieving and going into a rebuild mode to avoid being a perennial mediocre team. This trade came to me today:

I Give: ARodgers, Ingram, DJax
I Get: Stafford, Michel, Keenum, Crowell, 2019 2nd (#3-5) and 2020 1st

Notables on my SuperFlex squad:
QB: Rodgers, Luck, Mayfield
RB: Ingram, Duke, Penny
WR: Cooper, CDavis, Fuller
TE: Howard
2019: 1st (3), 2nd (3)
2020: 1st (2), 2nd (1)

I’m looking for opinions about the value of this trade... thanks!

Easy pass, IMO.

Stafford is not a QB that will win you a league. Crowell and Keenum are guys that you like on your bench. A 2019 2nd and a random 2020 1st don't do that much for especially given the picks that you have.

Having a due of Rodgers and Luck (with an ascending Mayfield), however, can cover up a lot of holes. If you make this trade, you simply open up more holes in roster -- Rodgers to Stafford is a monumental drop; who knows about Michel?; the picks are just that -- without really solving anything else.

You actually have some good talent on your team, and your 5 1st-round picks in the next two years can fill it out quite nicely or be used to trade for veteran players. I see this trade as moving your from a retool to a rebuild without any noticeable assets coming back in return.

So, easy pass, IMO.

[frisco86]

I would do it. I like Michel more than Ingram for Dynasty. How many more years does Rodgers have? I like the other pieces including the'20 1st. You have Mayfield, so Rodgers is expendable since not competing this year.

[AlPal&Ange]

I like the trade but similarly to others, I would do your best to not have Ingram in that deal. I'd maybe try trading Ingram for a 2019 1st. Since your not competing this year.