Andrew Luck vs. Jared Goff?

[JPP's10thfinger]

Simple question, who would you rather have?

[BigBawseRoss]

goff. based on not trusting lucks health. thats all.

[Gator Sens]

I would rather have Luck due to his teams reliance on him and heavy workload. Health is a bit of a concern though with Luck

[CGW]

I would lean luck here, but both are great options.

Luck is arguably a better talent and will likely have more opportunities to throw the ball, which is why I lean that way. His health is trending in the right direction also. While I'm hesitant to think the o-line is fixed, he hasn't been sacked in 5 weeks.

[JPP's10thfinger]

I took Luck, had a trade set up to get one of them for a second rounder. Owner of Luck accepted first. I'm liking the direction of the coaching staff/front office a lot.

[Goddard]

Only benefit I can think for Goff is age. So if the 5 year difference doesn't bother you (Luck's only 29 and should play another 5 years at minimum at a high level), go with Luck.

[JDogil12]

The only football argument for Goff is that he has Mcvay. I think they're pretty equal, but I would rather Luck

[darewood11]

Put luck in the same spot as goff woth those weapons i think he looks better than goff. Hes done a lot this season with littlw talent in his receiving corps. Ty is still good but was hurt snd missed time. Give him another good wr on the opposite side.

[thomasscheeks]

Luck. Situations change and Luck is the more talented QB (I think lol)

[Duke Nuk’em]

Goff is great. Luck could be an all-timer. It's like comparing Phil Sims or Boomer Esiason to Elway or Marino. When he's done, I think Luck could be in the Elway/Marino conversation. I don't think the same is true of Goff...yet.