Golladay price tag?

[keebs3]

Looking to acquire Golladay for team 1.

I want to offer:

Collins, Breida (I know the owner likes him) and Christian Kirk.

Is that enough? If not, what should I add? He's not interested in Mike Williams.

Same owner has DJ Moore- is this closer to fair? I want Golladay, but will settle for Moore if I can get a fair deal.

[Gator Sens]

Seems like a nice offer to at least open a conversation on Galladay

[Jigga94]

I dont think it's bad for Golladay.

That's an overpay for Moore though. Him and Kirk should be pretty close

[jordanzs]

Fair offer. Myself as a Golladay owner, I would heavily consider it and possibly accept. I wouldn't be smashing the accept button or anything, but there's a decent chance I would take it.

[thomasscheeks]

I'm gonna have to disagree and say that's not that great of an offer.

Collins is worth pretty much nothing to me. Kirk has shown some flashes, but the Cards offense is terrible and there's no signs of them taking a big leap next year. The 49ers are likely to sign a big name RB in the off season or draft someone, significantly hurting Brieda's workload.

That's a lot of risk for what is looking like a legit stud in a high flying offense. Of course, you can always send it and find out, I'm just saying I wouldn't accept it and it would take a lot more to get it done.

[BigBawseRoss]

if im a golladay owner i see this as kirk for golladay and i prefer golladay

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

if im a golladay owner i see this as kirk for golladay and i prefer golladay

x2 for me Golladay = early 1st, and Kirk = late 1st

[Goddard]

I think Kirk will end up being better than Golladay on the long-run.

[Kkiddynamite]

I'm gonna have to disagree and say that's not that great of an offer.

Collins is worth pretty much nothing to me. Kirk has shown some flashes, but the Cards offense is terrible and there's no signs of them taking a big leap next year. The 49ers are likely to sign a big name RB in the off season or draft someone, significantly hurting Brieda's workload.

That's a lot of risk for what is looking like a legit stud in a high flying offense. Of course, you can always send it and find out, I'm just saying I wouldn't accept it and it would take a lot more to get it done.

This for me too. Kirk is the only piece Id be interested in and it would take more than Kirk to pry Golladay away for me

[Ryantacular]

Golladay and not close

[keebs3]

Well I guess the thing to take from this is some people like Collins long term, and some people hate him. I seem to remember most people being pretty high on Collins just a month ago.

[NFL123]

Golladay side. I don't see Collins being a starter next year, Brieda will be in a timeshare with McKinnon and Kirk may struggle if he is the WR1 in Arizona if Fitzgerald retires.

[TrojanDynasty32]

I think Collins will take the fall for Baltimore ignoring their OL. May be partly to blame as he hasn’t looked like the 2017 version. So, he adds little for me at this point.

McKinnon will be back next year & they gave him big $ for a reason. Not a good reason, but he’ll get touches because of it. That limits Breida’s Value.

So, it comes down to is Kirk close enough to Golladay? I would think not, but if the other guy likes Breida & believes in Kirk, it should at least get a conversation going, but ultimately, I think it will take more to get a deal done.

[Titans95]

I dont think it's bad for Golladay.

That's an overpay for Moore though. Him and Kirk should be pretty close

Agreed on Moore. I like him more but I think you'd be adding too much. Both have shown about the same their rookies years and both are talented enough to not say one is clearly ahead of the other.