Judge this Evans trade please!

[Gunnar997]

My 16 team dynasty leagues trade deadline was last night. One owner who is in 15th place has been trying to get Guice from me for awhile. The first place team just made a trade with him taking Zeke/Landry and giving him Bell/Evans. So the 15th place team came to me offering to move Evans. After hours of back and fourth we settled on,

Gave: Guice, Corey Davis, Early-Mid Second Round pick

Get: Mike Evans, Early-Mid Third round pick

The owner that traded him Bell is furious and demanding the trade to be reversed. I actually think this trade is good for both team. After Bell his other RBs are Brieda and Jamaal Williams. Which next season both probably are out of starting roles.

Is this a decent trade or did I absolutely “destroy him” like the other owner says? I also think his Bell trade is questionable but I didn’t say anything.

[Dynasty_Analyst]

If anything I think he fleeced him harder than you did

[vixen]

If anything I think he fleeced him harder than you did

100%

[thomasscheeks]

That's a pretty even trade, I actually like the Guice/Davis side better.

As for him demanding the trade be reversed, sounds like he's one of those guys that doesn't understand how trade vetoes work. Trade vetoes exist for collusion and collusion only. Even if the trade were terrible, he has no say in it. People are free to trade their players however they see fit, so long as they aren't doing it to purposely help a team win. This is a fairly even trade based on the managers' personal valuations, and I see no problem with it.

Copy and paste this statement to share with him if you want

[Gator Sens]

I like the Guice and Davis side on this deal much more

[FantasyFoosball]

Piling on, give me Guice, Davis, and the 2nd.

That other owner shouldn't be playing dynasty football if that's the way he feels. I would not want to be in a league with someone like that.

He robbed the guy with his trade, and I think the guy got the better of your deal.

[BradysBunch]

Piling on, give me Guice, Davis, and the 2nd.

That other owner shouldn't be playing dynasty football if that's the way he feels. I would not want to be in a league with someone like that.

He robbed the guy with his trade, and I think the guy got the better of your deal.

Agree with this

[BelichekYourSelf]

My 16 team dynasty leagues trade deadline was last night. One owner who is in 15th place has been trying to get Guice from me for awhile. The first place team just made a trade with him taking Zeke/Landry and giving him Bell/Evans. So the 15th place team came to me offering to move Evans. After hours of back and fourth we settled on,

Gave: Guice, Corey Davis, Early-Mid Second Round pick

Get: Mike Evans, Early-Mid Third round pick

The owner that traded him Bell is furious and demanding the trade to be reversed. I actually think this trade is good for both team. After Bell his other RBs are Brieda and Jamaal Williams. Which next season both probably are out of starting roles.

Is this a decent trade or did I absolutely “destroy him” like the other owner says? I also think his Bell trade is questionable but I didn’t say anything.

Piling on. The guy complaining is the one who trade raped the 15th place team. Your trade was extremely fair. You may have even overpaid by a little.

[PTW32]

It looks pretty even to me. I traded Evans + Agholor away in a rebuild for Sony Michel, DJ Moore and OJ Howard (in a 2 TE leauge). I think thats pretty comparable to what you gave up.

[Gunnar997]

Thanks everyone! I wasn’t really all about moving Guice and Davis but going into next season only starting two RBs and already having Gurley and Chubb I felt comfortable enough to try to upgrade Davis. Appreciate everyone’s responses on this.