Gurley for Barkley +

[CooperCrush]

Team in sig 2, what would need to be added to Barkley to get Gurley. Would Cooper be enough, too much, not enough? Or should I just keep Gurley and try and get depth another way?

[PercyR1]

Why would you want to sell Barkley...? Hes on a terrible team and O-line and hes still absolutely crushing his avg Points per game. Can you imagine if the giants improve what Barkley could do....

[BelichekYourSelf]

Dynasty wise I think Gurley and Barkley are pretty equal. Gurley is a better scoring option now but Barkley is maybe more talented and 3 years younger. Gurley is in the ideal situation for a RB. Barkley is in the exact opposite. Like was said above. Imagine what Barkley would put up in a better situation? And his situation can only get better from here.... right?

[bills2]

Yea I have a tough time moving Barkley, even for Gurley

[Goddard]

Keep Gurley, you don't need the depth. Gurley's only 24 years old and on an LT like tear. You would hope Barkley can be as good as that someday, but why would you give that up when you already have it?

[Favrezilla]

Why would you want to sell Barkley...? Hes on a terrible team and O-line and hes still absolutely crushing his avg Points per game. Can you imagine if the giants improve what Barkley could do....

Lmao. Your posts are always good for a chuckle.

Keep Gurley - at his best saquon MIGHT be as good as Gurley and MIGHT Luck into as good of a situation.

It would take a lot more for me to move Gurley for Barkley

[badbuddah]

Sometimes I wonder what people expect in fantasy. Like you have the ceiling at the position, the Standard Bearer, and you think that you can go higher? I'd maybe understand this is Gurley was older, but I don't understand this move at all. I love Barkley, and of course he is probably #2 behind Gurley in Dynasty in most formats, but you already have #1 for the next several years...

[Benflicky]

I would go for the Barkley side, I don’t thonk there is much of a difference between the two and adding a decent player should make me go the Barkley side

[Dynasty_Analyst]

Due to the lack of depth at RB they are by far and away the most valuable dynasty options. Lucky enough to have Barkley on both teams below. If your an owner of either I dont know why you would switch there both great. I myself wouldn't trade Barkley for Gurley simply due to age. In PPR hes scored almost 60 more points than Barkley thats all touchdowns which has a lot to do with his team and line. Maybe in non ppr I could lean Gurley but Barkely is such a target machine to its hard to get rid of him for anybody. I'd love to see what he can do with a decent line there having a lot better luck throwing to him than running him