2QB counter advice

[Grimmer]

10-team 2QB... guy wants a QB. Original offer was Mike Davis for Eli but don’t have much faith in Davis. He said he’d upgrade WR for me but offered an injured Hilton + Mike Davis for Corey Davis + Beathard. Looking for counter ideas or should I just hold?

My team:
QB Brady, Stafford, Eli, Darnold, Allen, Beathard
RB Gurley, Mixon, Drake, AP, Buck
WR AB, Hill, Sanders, Davis, Baldwin, DJax, Cole, Enunwa
TE Burton, Reed

His team:
QB Brees, Wentz
RB Kamara, Howard, Conner, Lindsay, Gio, Mack, Wilkins, Penny, MDavis, Ekeler
WR OBJ, KAllen, Thielen, Hilton, Sanu, Goodwin, Godwin, Miller
TE McDonald, Henry

[Jigga94]

I'd rather have Corey than TY and Mike

[Goddard]

Maybe he'll do Eli for Gio straight up. You can at least handcuff Mixon that way.

[skip]

Maybe he'll do Eli for Gio straight up. You can at least handcuff Mixon that way.

I like this idea. I'd also make that trade for Mack instead or try to get both by adding something. Mack is a great trade target atm.

[dblj1199]

Gil as a handcuff for Eli or Beathard is a easy accept for me.

[moishetreats]

Players that I would take straight up for either Eli or CJ (that are reasonable to expect in return -- i.e., not including OBJ...):

RB Conner, Lindsay, Gio, Mack, Penny (?)
WR Hilton, Goodwin (?), Godwin, Miller (?)
TE Henry

Good luck!

[Grimmer]

Thanks everyone! I went the Gio route but asked for and he accepted...

Give: C.J. Beathard + Keelan Cole
Get: Gio Bernard + TY Hilton

I figure Hilton will be a solid WR4 option once healthy and losing Beathard doesn’t hurt a ton since I have all the QBs. Gives him a chance to win this week too.

[skip]

Thanks everyone! I went the Gio route but asked for and he accepted...

Give: C.J. Beathard + Keelan Cole
Get: Gio Bernard + TY Hilton

I figure Hilton will be a solid WR4 option once healthy and losing Beathard doesn’t hurt a ton since I have all the QBs. Gives him a chance to win this week too.

Jeepers... Beathard??? I don't care for Eli but I'd have zero interest in Beathard... You killed this trade

[moishetreats]

Thanks everyone! I went the Gio route but asked for and he accepted...

Give: C.J. Beathard + Keelan Cole
Get: Gio Bernard + TY Hilton

I figure Hilton will be a solid WR4 option once healthy and losing Beathard doesn’t hurt a ton since I have all the QBs. Gives him a chance to win this week too.

Nice!!

[sugbear65]

I'd actually rather have given Eli. Not that I'm a Beathard fan(though he's not been horrible from a fantasy perspective), but I have more faith in him finishing out the season as a starting QB then I do in Manning at this point.

[Grimmer]

I'd actually rather have given Eli. Not that I'm a Beathard fan(though he's not been horrible from a fantasy perspective), but I have more faith in him finishing out the season as a starting QB then I do in Manning at this point.

Eli played Thursday and he was needing a QB this week. I’d have preferred trading Eli as well if it were still an option. Beathard has put up good fantasy #s both weeks now.