TRADE: My Carr & Coleman vs. A. Smith, C. McCoy, Duke Johnson, 19.1, 19.2

[HSCTiger]

Hey guys,

I'm in a 16-team SFlex and got a trade proposal.

I give up: Carr, Tevin Coleman

He gives up: Alex Smith, Colt McCoy, Duke Johnson, 19.1 and 19.2

His original offer was Smith and a 19.2 for Carr, and I asked how we can get a 1st included in the deal.

My current roster is:

QB: Carr, C. Kelly, C.Kessler, M. Glennon, K. Sloter
RB: Elliott, T. Coleman, A. Jones, CJA, D. Henderson (and some TS guys like M. Walton)
WR: Allen, Diggs, D. Parker, Callaway, S. Shepard, DJ Moore, C. Samuel, W. Snead, J. Grant (and some other speculative/TS like Lasley)
TE: Ebron, Gates, Tonyan, Arnold (H. Henry on IR)

I have 2 2nds in the 19 draft, but no first. In a 16-team SFlex, I doubt I'll see any QB prospects in the 2nd round.

Should I take this deal?

I really like Coleman's outlook for next season on a new deal possibly with a new team, but for all we know he could end up in a timeshare somewhere. What I really need is to get another QB prospect somehow. This trade would get me a first rounder (presumably top 8) in order to get one. Duke Johnson I think can only go up from here with Mayfield or potentially in the future with another team. Colt McCoy is Smith's handcuff, etc.

What do you guys think?