Discussions Ongoing: Miller + 2020 2nd for John Brown + 2020 1st?

[Avery]

Team 2 below.

I listed to the wisdom of the forum and passed on a previous (potential) offer but discussions are ongoing. Don't want to muddy the forum, but since this is a different enough offer, I thought it was clearer if I started a new post.

I have a guy asking for Miller or Collins. Personally, I'd rather sell Miller of the two as I am (despite two weeks of evidence) still optimistic about Collins going forward. Now I don't need both of them, they are my RB3/4 and 1 only need to start 1 RB, but in a vacuum I think they have more value than Brown.

My plan was to wait for RB injuries to hit, as they always do, and then trade one to a desperate team but to noodling on offering:
I give: L. Miller & 2020 2nd
I get: John Brown & 2020 1st

I'm collecting 2020 1st round picks and althoughI have by no means given up on the year, but I'm sitting at 0-2 and this just may not be my year.

My thought is, if Johnson can come around at all, this wouldn't hurt my starting lineup (may even help it) and I'm getting some future return.

What says the forum. Would this be a good return on Miller?
Would love to hear your opinion. His team is listed below if you have a better idea. Thanks!

His team:
QBs: Ryan, Bortles, Rosen
RBs: Cogen, Gurley, D. Johnson, A. Jones, Montgomery, Yeldon
WRs: Allen, John Brown, Goodwin, Hilton, Tre'Quan Smith
TEs: Bruton, Ertz, Graham

[Goddard]

I'm assuming the title is incorrect because it states that you'd be giving a 1st with Miller. Assuming you're giving Miller and a 2nd and getting Brown and a 1st, I'd say it's fairly even.

[jeffster]

Yes, as long as the 1st is on the Brown side it's reasonable.

[Avery]

I'm assuming the title is incorrect because it states that you'd be giving a 1st with Miller. Assuming you're giving Miller and a 2nd and getting Brown and a 1st, I'd say it's fairly even.

Yup. I screwed up the title.

It is my Miller and 2020 2nd for his Brown and 2020 1st.

Honestly, not sure he'd go for it because people seem to hate Miller in this league.

[BigBawseRoss]

take brown and the first and dont be stupid, trade collins and not miller.

[Avery]

take brown and the first and dont be stupid, trade collins and not miller.

Thanks for the reply!

You think Miller has more long term upside than Collins? In other words, in dynasty, yo-yos have Miller above Collins?