SF trade offer

[tom14cat14]

Sorry for another thread.

Give: Watson, T. Coleman, Godwin, Vannett
Get: Winston, Evans

Update: I rejected above and he asked what he could add. Posted links to rosters.

This is a SF and Bestball. Not in sig. I like my guys. I like Watson and Godwin a lot. Value on a trade calc I use as info not end all be all says I should take it. If I do this I will not have a second QB while Winston is out unless Rosen starts. I am not sure what to think about Evans and if he really is the stud we think he is. Am I just falling in love too much with 2 guys that haven't shown enough or long enough?

[Tennisbuck]

I would stay put. I love both Godwin and Watson

[moishetreats]

I would do it.

If you wanted to go by ADP, Watson and Evans are in the same ballpark. And, in an SF, I'd much rather have Winston AND the two roster spots than the other three guys.

If you wanted to do a position comp, Evans is, IMO, by faaaar more valuable than the three non-QBs you'd be giving up (and, again, you get two roster spots). Despite what the dynasty community thinks, I don't think that the gap between Watson and Winston is massive -- and it's certainly not big enough to compensate for passing up on Evans.

[vixen]

so if this is best ball, how does the ww work?

i kind of disagree with moishetreats...in a best ball league, you want some good depth, because the best scores are chosen..
that said, no offense, but that does not look like a championship roster
if you make that trade, i don't think you will have a starting QB for the first 3 games

[Goddard]

Watson should be the best piece in this deal. I'd keep your side.

[tom14cat14]

so if this is best ball, how does the ww work?

i kind of disagree with moishetreats...in a best ball league, you want some good depth, because the best scores are chosen..
that said, no offense, but that does not look like a championship roster
if you make that trade, i don't think you will have a starting QB for the first 3 games

WW works the same. This is a startup not in my Sig. No team really looks like they have a stacked team, as of now. This team I did trade back and I gained 1 1st and 2 2nds for next years rookie draft. We have 30 roster spots. Best players on WW
Dorset, Decker, Fat Rob, AP based on own %.

[Dynos]

Keep watson. He was insane last year before the injury.

Winston is a big question mark right now and hes value keep dropping.

[tom14cat14]

So I ended up deciding to reject his offer. I told him it was fair but I want to stick with my guys. He asked is there anything he can add to make this work. Oh man

[tom14cat14]

His Roster https://www62.myfantasyleague.com/2018/ ... =07&F=0004

Mine- https://www62.myfantasyleague.com/2018/ ... =07&F=0008