Diggs or Cook full PPR

[Dynasty19]

Who you rather in a full PPR league? What side needs to add and how far is the gap?

Stefon Diggs or Dalvin Cook

[abloom]

Diggs but it really depends on the team/league setup. Diggs has a longer track record

[Kkiddynamite]

I like Diggs this year... I like Dalvin and his talent is undeniable but I think Murray will get more touches than people think and would like

[smallxl]

Diggs for me although if you're asking for cook or Diggs you need to add. That's the way it works

[SteveMaddensShoes]

Diggs is safer but either is fine depending on needs

[kmbryant09]

I think Cook has more value, so I'm surprised to see all of the Diggs responses. I do like Diggs, but Cook is a tier 2 RB after the studs (DJ / Bell / Gurley / Zeke / Barkley) and RBs are making a comeback.

[BigBawseRoss]

who the hell is voting on this? diggs relatives???? lol this is cook by a lot

[Kkiddynamite]

who the hell is voting on this? diggs relatives???? lol this is cook by a lot

I like Cook and agree hes a tier 2 back... but I wanna see a guy play more than 4 games... Again I like Cook and Im on the bandwagon like everybody else... but I understand the Diggs votes and wouldnt be shocked at all to see some sort of timeshare.... I dont think Cook is gonna come
back and Murray just ride the pine until he needs a a drink or to catch his breath. Can see Murray getting 10 touches a game and Cook getting 15-20

[chalorpas]

Diggs but it really depends on the team/league setup. Diggs has a longer track record

Diggs has a longer track record of mediocrity... I'd rather have Cook pretty easily.

[HughHoney]

Cook for me

[JJRules]

I would 100% lol if somebody offered me Diggs for my Cook straight up.

[Minnkota]

I would 100% lol if somebody offered me Diggs for my Cook straight up.

I guess I just don’t understand this kind of a reaction towards a trade offer concerning two fairly evenly priced players. They are about 6-8 spots apart from each other in adp, and the poll results tell you that people see them as similar assets as well. It’s at least close enough to begin negotiations.

We also don’t know the starting requirements, unless I missed them. I own Cook in a ppr start 1rb/1wr/5 flex league and would probably make this deal if it were offered, as rbs are a bit devalued. In a conventional start 2 rb league, I would probably need a bit added to Diggs, but it wouldn’t need to be a ton.

[Cowboysfan33]

Diggs for me. I also think Lat Murray will be used more than people think and I know it’s an “if” but if Diggs can just play a full season, the sky is the limit for him.

[FantasyFreak]

Diggs for me. I also think Lat Murray will be used more than people think and I know it’s an “if” but if Diggs can just play a full season, the sky is the limit for him.

I think Diggs is good, but I don't think he is as physical as other WR's his size, so I think "the sky" is debatable. I think 1200 yards and people should be ecstatic for whoever has him. This team has a great defensive and with Thielen, Cook, Rudolph, I can see a lot of spreading it around and having a great D doesn't help his chances of more pass attempts/targets.

[FantasyFreak]

I would 100% lol if somebody offered me Diggs for my Cook straight up.

Yeah that's just a good way to eliminate future trade partners. Not a poor offer. You tell them you value Cook for whatever reason you value him more, and move on. You're assuming too much off of 4 games and acting like they are stupid, despite the fact they are arguably taking more risk. Not cool IMO.