Delvin Cook , Evans Trade ?

[jojo5151]

For team 1 in sig
Was offered the 1.3 2018 for Evans, obviously not going to accept. Owner also has Delvin Cook. Was thinking of offering Evans & Breida for his 1.3 & Cook. Which side would you rather have?

[gameaholica]

I don't think he will accept, but you need rb help. I would try it, then draft an rb also.

[Titans95]

I would happily tell you not a chance in hell. if I was the 1.03 and Cook owner.

[jojo5151]

What should I add to it?

[HughHoney]

Yeah not close at all. Cook and Evans are very close. Breida is worth maybe a 3rd (although I haven’t been able to get that for him).

[HughHoney]

What should I add to it?

Adding Gordon or Godwin probably won’t get it done but might get a counter. Adding Thielen would make it fair.

[BelichekYourSelf]

Yeah not close at all. Cook and Evans are very close. Breida is worth maybe a 3rd (although I haven’t been able to get that for him).

Cooks and Evans are very close? Since when is an injury prone 23 year old RB with 350 career yards worth even remotely close to a 24 year old WR with 4 strait 1,000 yard seasons to start his career?

I'd need something like Cook and the 1.03 to move Evans. Wouldn't add anything.

[HughHoney]

Yeah not close at all. Cook and Evans are very close. Breida is worth maybe a 3rd (although I haven’t been able to get that for him).

Cooks and Evans are very close? Since when is an injury prone 23 year old RB with 350 career yards worth even remotely close to a 24 year old WR with 4 strait 1,000 yard seasons to start his career?

I'd need something like Cook and the 1.03 to move Evans. Wouldn't add anything.

So 1 career injury and now Cook is injury prone? Four 1000 yards seasons is a good NFL accomplishment but by itself it means about 100 fantasy points. Evans has 1 WR1 finish in 4 years. For me Evans is still a top 10 WR but I view Cook as a top 10 dynasty RB.

ETA: And the age difference is 2 years. Cook turned 23 a week ago and Evans turns 25 in 3 days.

[Dynasty4life]

Yeah not close at all. Cook and Evans are very close. Breida is worth maybe a 3rd (although I haven’t been able to get that for him).

Cooks and Evans are very close? Since when is an injury prone 23 year old RB with 350 career yards worth even remotely close to a 24 year old WR with 4 strait 1,000 yard seasons to start his career?

I'd need something like Cook and the 1.03 to move Evans. Wouldn't add anything.

So 1 career injury and now Cook is injury prone? Four 1000 yards seasons is a good NFL accomplishment but by itself it means about 100 fantasy points. Evans has 1 WR1 finish in 4 years. For me Evans is still a top 10 WR but I view Cook as a top 10 dynasty RB.

ETA: And the age difference is 2 years. Cook turned 23 a week ago and Evans turns 25 in 3 days.

Sorry but i have to agree, Cook has potential but Evans has proved it. Shelf life for WR's is longer than RB's. I would never trade Evans for Cook straight up, i would need more.
Give me Evans between the two.

[Mjvb5]

I wouldn’t add much more than a second to the Evans side. Don’t see how an Rn with 5 good games is close to a top 5wr for dynasty

[smallxl]

I wouldn’t add much more than a second to the Evans side. Don’t see how an Rn with 5 good games is close to a top 5wr for dynasty

This!...people get too wrapped up in shiny new toys. Evans side easy

[HughHoney]

I wouldn’t add much more than a second to the Evans side. Don’t see how an Rn with 5 good games is close to a top 5wr for dynasty

That’s the difference. You view Evans as a top 5 dynasty WR. I don’t. He certainly hasn’t proven that on the field yet.

[dblj1199]

I’d rather be on the 1.3 and Cook side here. Too me Evans and Cook are close to equal but adding the 1.3 I’d much rather have the Cook side. Breida is simply a throw in here.

[BelichekYourSelf]

Yeah not close at all. Cook and Evans are very close. Breida is worth maybe a 3rd (although I haven’t been able to get that for him).

Cooks and Evans are very close? Since when is an injury prone 23 year old RB with 350 career yards worth even remotely close to a 24 year old WR with 4 strait 1,000 yard seasons to start his career?

I'd need something like Cook and the 1.03 to move Evans. Wouldn't add anything.

So 1 career injury and now Cook is injury prone? Four 1000 yards seasons is a good NFL accomplishment but by itself it means about 100 fantasy points. Evans has 1 WR1 finish in 4 years. For me Evans is still a top 10 WR but I view Cook as a top 10 dynasty RB.

ETA: And the age difference is 2 years. Cook turned 23 a week ago and Evans turns 25 in 3 days.

Cook had several injuries in college as well. Want to know who else had 1 WR1 finish in his first for years? Deandre Hopkins. If you look at it he only has 2 WR1 finishes in 5 years, yet he's a top 3 dynasty asset right now. Evans has proven ELITE upside with a high end WR1 season already under his belt and a very solid floor. Which is extremely rare for a player his age. Cook has proven nothing.

My bad on the ages just looked at the number on MFL not that birthdays.

[saw061600]

The only way Cook is equal to Evans is if you're looking at ADP trade calculators.